Re: Jihad needs scientists



On Thu, 26 Oct 06 12:39:03 GMT, jmfbahciv@xxxxxxx wrote:

In article <iLOdnYf2fLhzz6LYRVnyuw@xxxxxxxxx>,
"T Wake" <usenet.es7at@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

<jmfbahciv@xxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:ehndut$8qk_001@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
In article <5bmdnTiQpMD62KPYnZ2dneKdnZydnZ2d@xxxxxxxxx>,
"T Wake" <usenet.es7at@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

<jmfbahciv@xxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:ehl0hs$8qk_001@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
In article <xeidnaGqVPjT7abYnZ2dnUVZ8s-dnZ2d@xxxxxxxxx>,
"T Wake" <usenet.es7at@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

<jmfbahciv@xxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:ehfm39$8qk_006@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

snipped

We [tinw] believe that Newtonian gravity is the best description of what
happens. Your lab experiment is limited by your equipment and your
understanding of what you are observing.

A new theory which matches the previous predictions and makes new
(sucessfully) testable ones will overhaul the old one. Until that happens we
[tinw] believe that the current theory is the *best*.

That is how science works.

I know. What you seem to omit is that the old method will still
continue to work within the range of the old measurements.

I get real annoyed when people say that Newtonian physics doesnt'
work. It does work with crude measurements of certain things.
I know what the scientists mean; but it's a bad form to use
because the cranks and the newbies do not know what they mean.
<snip>

/BAH
Newtonian mechanics though inaccurate is understandable to most
though for modern day engineering purposes it is
unreliable/inapplicable but
how many people/engineers are able to get an idea of what General
relativity really is about?

lemonjuice
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Canonical science today, two conferences on cosmology, Newtonian limits, nongeometrical gravity,
    ... Cosmology 2008 conference to participate with a work on Newtonian ... limits and our current understanding of relativistic gravity. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Doubts about relativity dogmas
    ... Translation: Newtonian gravity is wrong. ... those topics was just reading a pair of undergrad textbooks. ... you continue to maintain that question of the Newtonian limit ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Pioneer anomaly
    ... equipped with accurate transponders for suitable doppler and ranging. ... pure newtonian motion. ... You, relativists, fake the energy of a photon. ... You assume that a photon in newtonian gravity must ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Doubts about relativity dogmas
    ... Translation: Newtonian gravity is wrong. ... those topics was just reading a pair of undergrad textbooks. ... you continue to maintain that question of the Newtonian limit ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Pioneer anomaly
    ... equipped with accurate transponders for suitable doppler and ranging. ... pure newtonian motion. ... You, relativists, fake the energy of a photon. ... You assume that a photon in newtonian gravity must ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)