Re: Cpacitor discharge

On Feb 16, 2:32 pm, ehsjr <e...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Andrew Edge wrote:

<snip>

Hi Tom.

Lessee...the OP stated that the current is constant, not i=v/R.

For your information a Capacitor is an open circuit to a constant
current. So a capacitor generating constant current is impossible.

So you are saying this circuit won't work,
within any time limits, whatsoever:

/
+12 ----o o-----+--->|---+
| |
[R] |
| |
+--->|---+ I -> ~ 10 mA
| | -----
[1F] +---In|LM317|Out---+
| ----- |
| Adj [120R]
| | |
| +---------+
| |
| [R]
| |
Gnd -----------+---------------------------+

Check on Kirchoff's current law on the capacitor leads.
I hoped someone would have told him that.

The op is discharging a cap through an active load
which he says draws constant current. Such a circuit
is shown above.

After the switch has been closed for sufficient time
to fully charge the capacitor, it is opened. Will
the discharge be constant current, or does the circuit
suddenly lose the ability to regulate?

Ed

<snip>


You don't really think your logic will matter to him, do you, Ed?

Note that he wrote, "For your information a Capacitor is an open
circuit to a constant current." That would mean that in a loop
comprising a constant current source, a capacitor, and a resistor,
there would be no current through the resistor...

Sigh.

Cheers,
Tom

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Cpacitor discharge
    ... So a capacitor generating constant current is impossible. ... within any time limits, whatsoever: ... or does the circuit ... It appears you have not learned to recognize Monsieur LaPlace as being ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: Cpacitor discharge
    ... So a capacitor generating constant current is impossible. ... within any time limits, whatsoever: ... or does the circuit ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: Cpacitor discharge
    ... For your information a Capacitor is an open circuit to a constant ... So a capacitor generating constant current is impossible. ... The Op said he wass discharging through a Microcontroller lead, ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: Cpacitor discharge
    ... So a capacitor generating constant current is impossible. ... So you are saying this circuit won't work, ... within any time limits, whatsoever: ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: Cpacitor discharge
    ... So a capacitor generating constant current is impossible. ... within any time limits, whatsoever: ...
    (sci.electronics.design)