Re: OT: sea level 'rise' hmmmmm....



Jonathan Kirwan wrote:

Eeyore

In comparison Loehle accepted a little peer review criticism of his work virtually
instantly and republished with minor corrections inside ~ 6 months. The interesting
thing is that the criticism of Loehle's work was in minor detail only and did not
affect its basic premise, whereas Mann's work fell totally on its head.

No, he didn't deal with several other serious objections. Just one,
if I recall.

CITE !

His proxies show a record that matches the historical record brilliantly.something that
Mann totally failed to do.

How much more do you wish to rewrite HISTORY ?


Graham

.