Re: ...or you could report his SPAM--and shame him



I certainly agree that reposting the spam was a complete waste of bandwidth.
I will accept 50 lashes from an appropriately clad young lady.
Caesar Valenti

Calls for volunteers have gone out. 8-)

I never have understood the top-posting disdain.

The disdain comes when folks
don't trim out the bits that don't apply in any way to the response.
This usually goes hand-in-glove with top-posting.
An extreme example is
a 1-word response followed by a 60-line blockquote.

I can understand this if it was meant to be
a long discussion with many posts,
but for short term, single reply items, I think [top-posting] is better.
Of course, determining in advance what is short term
(or single reply) IS rather difficult!

As the Bard said, "Ah. There's the rub."
High marks on your understanding of the ancillary points.
The baffling part is that
your logic doesn't allow you to then loop back to the starting point.
(Again, proper trimming makes the most-accepted technique
less odious.)

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: temple/pyramid plans
    ... Usenet, no one on an unmoderated group can be stopped from posting. ... It might be that some folks here might also be ... explain your approach and your top-posting. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: PIREP - EnV Smart Phone
    ... I fail to see how not conforming with top-posting on a reply will result in ... software posting location lending to the idea that your preference is ... No. That's why I trim away what I'm not directly replying to. ... Trimming and top-posting are not mutually exclusive. ...
    (rec.aviation.piloting)
  • Re: Unicode in Delphi/VCL (yet again)
    ... As I've pointed out to the folks who hacked up VB in this regard (and you ... can quote me on this) "A new type of data requires a new data type.". ... Why is top-posting such a bad thing? ...
    (borland.public.delphi.non-technical)
  • Re: Congratulations to Clinton Fitch
    ... >Is that (top-posting) considered a no-no or something? ... Some folks have strong ... opinions. ... >Darren Humphries ...
    (microsoft.public.pocketpc)
  • Re: [SLE] Top posting (WAS: Re: [SLE] Printing quality)
    ... Please don't top post and trim your posts. ... And what practices do you advocate about trimming ... > messages to which one is responding? ... Top-posting promotes full ...
    (SuSE)