Re: Equipment, and the Useless Eco- legislation ...

On Sep 11, 6:28 am, "Arfa Daily" <arfa.da...@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Oh, and before everyone starts on the conspiracy theories about how the
manufacturers only want it to last just out of warranty so that they can
sell you another, I don't subscribe to this line of thinking. I believe that
poor reliability is down to the manufacturers cutting the cost to the bone
on component speccing, along with poor design by fresh-out-of-university
graduates who know all of the theory and none of the practice. As far as the
cost and availability of spares go, I think that this is basic profiteering
on the former, and that both are driven by the company bean-counters. There.
That's my rant for the week ...

I think you are about 30 degrees tangentally off the mark on the
causes, but pretty much dead-on with the results.

Keep a couple of points in mind:

a) Most "Name" manufacturers, even Denon, Sony, Yamaha, and Nakamichi
job out mostly all the content in their equipment. Vertical
integration such as in the past (Use names lost in the dimness of time
such as Philco or RCA that made _everything_ inside their equipment
except the wire from tubes to coils to speakers to the cabinet itself)
has pretty much vanished in the electronics industry.

b) Computerized manufacturing techniques within specialty
manufacturing facilities pretty much makes "similar" parts in long or
short runs commodity items vs. custom (bespoke) items after the first
50 or so roll down the line.

c) Keep in mind that WalMart is not the only end-user that chokes its
vendors and suppliers for lower prices. Consumer electronics
manufacturer end-users have an interesting technique of not paying for
inventory until it is actually installed in the item. So the supplier
is not about to make stock much further in advance than is certain to
be needed. He might not get paid for them.

So, Denon/Yamaha/Sony wants 12,000 transformers to a certain
specification. They _WILL NOT_ make them internally, but will job them
out to a transformer maker who will then deliver them *just in time*
as needed. Should the need be greater, the supplier will make more -
also just in time. Should the contract be cancelled, you can also bet
that he will have no surplus in his inventory either. Denon/Yamaha/
Sony then will make a bet on the number of spares that might be needed
(if any), buy them and then stop. They will also make an actuarial
decision as to how long they will support an item such that they might
consider a later run of such specialty parts... And that will be a
cold calculation: The cost of a later run vs. a very few pissed off
customers who likely wanted something "new" anyway. Where do you think
that calculation will fall? Especially if that costomer can be made to
smile with a $25 gift certificate?

That they are slowly and almost inexorably putting the repair shops
out of business is simply not their concern. As to warranty issues, it
would be far cheaper for them to do again what is done in the US,
pretty much replace any failed items (under warranty) out-of-hand with
the 'latest' version and trash the failed unit rather than maintain an
actual warranty service station with technician salaries, parts,
shipping/receiving and so forth. All that they really need is the
shipping/receiving bit. Keep in mind that if *you* are paying $499.99
at Best Buy/Circuit City for a AV receiver, it likely cost Denon/
Yamaha/Sony something under $100 to make and ship.

The "Government" has not a damned thing to do with it. It is the
consumer that drives these things... and the average consumer is well-
and-truly hypnotized into believing that "old" is junk and not worth
fixing. And that same thoroughly hypnotized consumer will be damned
before he is willing to subsidize his neighbor's job by supporting
reasonable trade policies and the consequential higher prices.

As in most things, we pretty much get exactly what we deserve... and
exactly what we wish for.

Peter Wieck
Wyncote, PA

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Solid Counter top for the DIY
    ... The manufacturers' warranties include fabrication and installation. ... My story is that it's because of profits and price. ... If it was because of warranty issues then the manufacturers could easily ... Jimbo gets his countertop home ...
    (rec.woodworking)
  • Re: Equipment, and the Useless Eco- legislation ...
    ... manufacturers only want it to last just out of warranty so that they can ... poor reliability is down to the manufacturers cutting the cost to the ... As to warranty issues, it ... consumer that drives these things... ...
    (sci.electronics.repair)
  • Re: Dell computers: bad deal
    ... you're dealing with a dozen or more different manufacturers. ... but because home builders tend to buy better quality parts than ... well as many stores that resell them), offer extended warranty plans. ... like Dell to fix things according to their warranties knows that the cost is ...
    (misc.consumers)
  • Re: Consumer Product Safety Comm. to discuss proposed SawStop technology safety rule
    ... your argument that this is a PROFIT issue on the part of the ... manufacturers is flaccid. ... The cost of the product passed onto the consumer has a ... If every manufacturer is mandated to have the Sawstop, then the consumer is ...
    (rec.woodworking)
  • Re: Matsui LM19W1 (stuck in standby)
    ... and has environmental costs which are ... another with a shiny new 2 year warranty on it. ... this stuff,and it is the manufacturers who are responsible ... recycling directives to be implemented in this less-than-ideal way. ...
    (sci.electronics.repair)
Quantcast