Re: Earth expansion - puzzled......

From: J. Taylor (jota_at_gorge.NOSPAM.net)
Date: 02/08/05 

Date: Tue, 08 Feb 2005 07:08:40 -0800

On Tue, 08 Feb 2005 06:01:04 GMT, "Hank Oredson"
<horedson@earthlink.net> wrote:

>"J. Taylor" <jota@gorge.NOSPAM.net> wrote in message
>news:pqcg01d8t4nucbq64r0ev0iberkfb2947d@4ax.com...
>> On 08 Feb 2005 02:57:43 GMT, bigdakine@aol.comGetaGrip (Bigdakine)
>> wrote:
>>
>>>>Subject: Re: Earth expansion - puzzled......
>>>>From: J. Taylor jota@gorge.NOSPAM.net
>>>>Date: 2/7/05 3:37 PM Hawaiian Standard Time
>>>>Message-id: <rn5g01hg9pjvifgnj60tkumh7m5622c4f1@4ax.com>
>>>>
>>>>On 06 Feb 2005 04:07:32 GMT, bigdakine@aol.comGetaGrip (Bigdakine)
>>>>wrote:
>>>>
>>>>>>Subject: Earth expansion - puzzled......
>>>>>>From: eugene@dynagen.co.za
>>>>>>Date: 2/5/05 9:26 AM Hawaiian Standard Time
>>>>>>Message-id: <1107631590.829026.241160@c13g2000cwb.googlegroups.com>
>>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>><snip good post>
>>>>>
>>>>>>Anybody care to correct and edify me on this matter? (The bushed
>>>>>>looney legionnaire or any of his supporters need not reply).
>>>>>
>>>>>Well Eugene you are doomed in their view. You have the audacity to
>>>>>actually
>>>>>use numbers.
>>>>
>>>>And the great big number for PT, subduction to spreading has to be 1:1
>>>>within a reasonable period of time. Otherwise the Earth begins to
>>>>shrink, or expand.
>>>
>>>LOL
>>
>> No? I thought Gerald just told us PT is consistent with other
>> sciences, just how does PT pull this off so it does not have to be a
>> 1:1 ratio?
>
>Um ... engage brain a bit ... think about it.
>The answer is so simple as to be humorous.

I am sure it is, in your mind!

>
>>>>And it is this constraint which is lacking the ocean's crust age map
>>>>from NOAA. The length, height, width, and time do not fit, but it
>>>>does fit expansion, that impossibility.
>>>
>>>Form what I've seen of EE models, anything can fit expansion. Including
>>>subduction.
>>
>> Model? It is suppose to be a map of the ocean's crust ages.
>
>Cart, horse, reverse.

You do understand the mechanism for EE is EXPANSION?

The unanswered question is what would cause the expansion.

Which creates the conundrum, if expansion is an impossibility, why
does so much of the Earth, if not all, have features which fits
expansion? You can be like George, and just pretend the evidence does
not exist, but that only makes them go away in the little world which
you live.

>
>> But this is the major difference between plate tectonics and expanding
>> Earth. PT tries to explain the evidence so it fits with an Earth with
>> a constant radius, EE just looks at the evidence and say where it
>> points.
>
>Cart, horse, reverse.

What I wrote above is a contrasting statement, not a sequential one,
where something follows from the other. You did know this right?

So the cart, horse, reverse has to do with what?

>
>> Fundamental difference. One tries to explain the facts, the other
>> just follows the facts to a logical conclusion.
>
>Huh? More total blather.

Blather in your mind means what?

>
>> Big difference.
>
>If earth expansion is so obviously correct, you would have a quick,
>easy, and obvious explanation for that factor of ten to the seventh.

Why would I have "a quick, easy, and obvious explanation" for your
imagined proof?

JT

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Where Matter Comes from For Planetary Growth
    ... scientists who have long endorsed the notion that the Earth has undergone ... gross expansion or growth. ... ubiquitous and there is strong evidence of the growth of Europa, Ganymede, ... growth advocates as to the cause of expansion or growth but nevertheless ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: FAQS - Earth Expansion
    ... >matters plate tectonics, I don't see much evidence of 'meshing'. ... I knew some folks who work on tectonic modelling and earth ... There is expansion, and there is ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: Where Matter Comes from For Planetary Growth
    ... scientists who have long endorsed the notion that the Earth has undergone ... gross expansion or growth. ... ubiquitous and there is strong evidence of the growth of Europa, Ganymede, ... growth advocates as to the cause of expansion or growth but nevertheless ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Owens Two-Phase Model of Earth Expansion
    ... > I'm saying that in both PT and EE you can't divorce the power source ... >> evidence for expansion, no mechanism, and needs plate tectonics to ... > On evidence of EE, ... contracting Earth too. ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: Earth expansion - puzzled......
    ... Or any evidence of net change in the size of the earth ... > accumulation of cosmic matter would see to that. ... oceanic expansion between currently existing continents. ...
    (sci.geo.geology)