Re: Expanding Earth Video


"Aidan Karley" <doIlookDAFTenoughTOpost@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote in message
news:VA.00000e2c.1024609f@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
In article <VA.00000e18.1a4032e9@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, Aidan
Karley wrote:
it'll take a while. But I've got a weekend's news to catch up on in the
mean time.) and see just how kookish the boy is.

Went through the first half-hour and there are several points that
stand out, which are identical
to Don's maunderings, and his lack of answers :
- There is no hint as to what physical process has lead to the
increase in volume of the Earth
that is required by his theory;
- He constantly decries the occurrence of subduction, without once
addressing the geological
reasons for believing it to be happening now (fault plane solutions, high
pressure-gradient metamorphic
suites.
- Powerpoint is as much a problem for him as for anyone else.
- The first 30 minutes he does little but replay various sets of
animations from his "Masters
Thesis". If that was the whole content of his thesis I'd be asking who
considered this unsupported
muttering to be of a passable quality.
Why does he go for, specifically, an exponential rate of expansion?

35 minutes - "gravitational collapse of crust". Strange name for
the flattening of the curvature
of segments of crust as the earth expands. That's a geometric necessity.
Ah - he uses this to provide a
reason for intracratonic extension - indeed he runs it into claiming that
the Red Sea is an example of
this collapse process, and not an ocean basin developing.
42 minutes and he appears to be claiming that intra-cratonic
extension was the expression of
earth expansion in that period. So from the Permian back to the
Mesoproterozoic he goes around closing
intracratonic basins to accommodate his shrinking Earth. Still no
explanation of where he gets his
material from. No explanation of why the "EE-tectonic" style changed at
around the start of the
Mesozoic.
Now, why is he stressing that the Atlantic-Indian and Pacific
oceans were (in his
reconstructions) separate and possibly had different salinities and
faunas ... Oh, he sees the draining
of one ocean into another as being a cause for mass extinctions. Water
running uphill? Or ocean's worth
of salt deposition? Conflicting data I leave as an exercise for the
reader.
I'll have to watch the 3rd third of it tomorrow.

Has don exploded yet? Did anyone get hit in the killfile by the
shrapnel?

--
Aidan Karley, FGS
Aberdeen, Scotland,
Location: 57°10'11" N, 02°08'43" W (sub-tropical Aberdeen), 0.021233

You were braver than I. I watched about 25 minutes of it before I deleted
the entire file off my computer. Yes, his rant has the same problem that
all other proponents of this hypothesis have, as you describe above. Which
is why I completely lost interest and just axed the file. I don't know if
Don's head has committed suicide yet. I suspect it will, but hopefully
I'll never see the ugly results.

George


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Expanding Earth Video
    ... In article, Aidan Karley wrote: ... - There is no hint as to what physical process has lead to the increase in volume of the Earth ... No explanation of why the "EE-tectonic" style changed at around the start of the ... of one ocean into another as being a cause for mass extinctions. ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: Earth expansion - parameters for discussion
    ... > you didn't get it from he planet earth (oh right. ... double the length of MOR to assumed 'subduction' zone (Maxlow has a full ... MORs are all twinned, i.e. producing crust either ... MILLIONS of cubic km of ocean crust 'slab' must stack up vertically ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: Owens Two-Phase Model of Earth Expansion
    ... You're claiming earth expansion, ... > If you're saying that cratons were the initial continents, ... >> Unless, of course, the original ocean basins were formed from impact basins. ... >> evidence to support either slow or fast hypothesis. ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: More for the Slow Man - Rising Sea Level Claim a Total Fraud
    ... other factors affecting the Earth, but it certainly could not be more. ... pack ice for much of the year, so that while the Artic is warming up ... rapidly, the Arctic ocean under the ice is stuck at -2C, and won't ... expand at all. ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: Owens Two-Phase Model of Earth Expansion
    ... > at the expense of the geology leading to 'belief'. ... > 'Think' and the Earth moves. ... The ocean floor ages on their own suggest ... So I think the answer to the riddle lies in explaining the seafloor ...
    (sci.geo.geology)