Re: mechanism for planetary growth


"Charles Cagle" <s_k_y_bolt99@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:s_k_y_bolt99-1508060121460001@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
The Herbig-Haro object known as HH-30 is undergoing a cyclic process of
shooting out huge blobs, each of which is estimated to be twice the size
of our solar system, like machine gun bullets. Right there in front of
the entire pseudoscientific community of putative astrophysicists and
cosmologists HH-30 is demonstrating that it is a huge matter creation
engine.

This claim is incorrect and not supported by the evidence simply because
there is no evidence that HH-30 is creating matter. The evidence is simply
that it is ejecting the matter that is piling up onto the surface of the
object from its previous created accretion disk.

<snip>

But from the world of pseudophysics... er astrophysics, these gentlemen
tell us that HH-30 is a young star and that it has an accretion disk and
that somehow the matter is flowing inward from this accretion disk to the
center and then being ejected out the ends. Details of how this all
happens are quite fuzzy

Oh yes, gravity is such a fuzzy issue. NOT!

<snip>

What is oh so cool about HH-30 and similar stellar jet systems is that
they are observed to have a proper motion across the spacial background
that is opposite to the direction of their ejecta. So, here's this
putative accretion disk that somehow manages to scoot across the sky...
pretty tricky stuff and very neat mechanism to convert the putative
rotational energy of an accretion disk that hasn't actually been detected
or proven to be such into a pulsed jet.

Umm, The accretion disk not only exists, it has been detected by the
Hubble:

http://hubblesite.org/newscenter/newsdesk/archive/releases/2000/32/video/b

That the stellar jet ejects matter normal to its proper motion should come
as no surprise to anyone, since the mechanism for matter ejection is its
very strong magnetic field, which just happens to be oriented at an angle
normal to the star's proper motion. The sun, too, has a magnetic field
which, on average, is oriented nearly normal to its proper motion.

<snipped more looney rantings>

George


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: mechanism for planetary growth
    ... This claim is incorrect and not supported by the evidence simply ... there is no evidence that HH-30 is creating matter. ... object from its previous created accretion disk. ... If I point out that a closed e loop ought to display the features ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: mechanism for planetary growth
    ... This claim is incorrect and not supported by the evidence simply because ... there is no evidence that HH-30 is creating matter. ... of the object from its previous created accretion disk. ... That the stellar jet ejects matter normal to its proper motion should come ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: mechanism for planetary growth
    ... there is no evidence that HH-30 is creating matter. ... object from its previous created accretion disk. ... That the stellar jet ejects matter normal to its proper motion should come ... very strong magnetic field, which just happens to be oriented at an angle ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: mechanism for planetary growth
    ... This claim is incorrect and not supported by the evidence simply because ... there is no evidence that HH-30 is creating matter. ... object from its previous created accretion disk. ... oscillation characteristics of a photon.. ...
    (sci.geo.geology)