Re: evidences against subduction theory


"Florian" <first_name@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1i1qc67.fspbsjbydwg6N%first_name@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
George <george@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

"Florian" <first_name@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1i1h5g1.14tfyz3d9ocm2N%first_name@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
George <george@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:


The crust is not elastic?

If the crust is pulled down then released, it won't go upper than its
orginal position.

The physical evidence (particularly from the 2004 Sumatran earthquake)
indicates otherwise.

So according to the eminent geologist "Georgette", the subducting slab
force the overiding *** to bend down then bend up when it is
"released". Mon vieux, Tu dérailles totalement.

Hold a popcicle stick horizontally at one end between the thumb and
forefinger of your right hand (left, if that is more comfortable for you).
Take the index finger of your other hand and slowly depress the end of the
stick downward, then release it. Repeat as many times as necessary, or
until you come to your senses.

Hahaha! When one plate slides over another, there is NECESSARILY A
DECREASE IN SURFACE AREA OF THE PLATES INVOLVED, AS A WHOLE. This has
been
demonstrated time and time again, floppy.

You can't even get that right georgette.
The raising diapirs push upper terrain up and on the sides (tectonic
trasport) which yields overthrusting of nearby terrain. So there is no
surface decrease, but volume increase because a new layer is emplaced.
It follows logically that since volume increased, surface globally
increased.

Diapirs produce both high angle normal and reverse faults, not shallow
angle thrust faults, Floppy. The other problem is where are these global
diapirs, Floppy? They don't show up on any seismic maps, nor surface
geologic maps I am aware of.

You start out with two plates of specific surface areas. You slide one
over the other (or slide one under the other, as the case may be). The
result invariably is that the overall surface area of both plates together
DECREASES, while the thickness of the combined plates INCREASES. You also
get crustal shortening due to crumpling (melange - look it up).

| surface area | | surface area |
______________ ______________
|______________| |______________|
Plate 1 plate 2


Plate 2
overriding plate 1
______________ _____
|______________| | Increased thickness
|______________| __|__

| Decreased
Surface area |

George


.

Quantcast