Re: What happens here, anyway?



Stuart wrote:

On Nov 29, 3:45 am, auxotectonics_deletethis@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
(Florian) wrote:
Stuart <bigdak...@xxxxxxx> wrote:
On Nov 28, 6:11 am, auxotectonics_deletethis@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
(Florian) wrote:
mike3 <mike4...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Your claim violates physics (e.g. conservation of mass-energy,
conservation of momentum, etc.)

nope. You do. You assume that conservation of mass-energy, momentum is
violated. You have no evidence supporting that view, you cannot be
certain that Earth is a closed system.

I can't be certain there are no pink unicorns either. But that is not
a reason I should expend time entertaining the possibility they exist.

Yet another big epistemological mistake.

We don't need pink unicorns to explains facts. We need matter
condensation inside planets to explain facts.

Got it?



No we do not. We have a theory that explains the facts and doesn't
require supernatural explanations. Your *hypothesis* is ad hoc
nonsense.

That's the problem with theory, Stuart, that you seem oblivious to: it
begins with what you have to explain. It's an incestuous circle, just
waiting to be knocked down with the next one. It's quite different
from an observation. You continually seem to be labouring under the
impression that Earth Expansion is a theory - with no mechanism.

You don't get it, ..do you?



You can whine till the cows come home.

Stuart


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: The important question for the Expanding Earth believers.
    ... Stuart, one day you will realize that geosciences have to rely heavily ... sample from the inner earth. ... credit for publishing what is perhaps the shortest paper in JGR in ... as he can now say he published in JGR. ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: Kook warning, Oriel36
    ... > community' see the importance of the Earth as an astronomical body ... > figures in the discussion of crustal evolution - or evolution of the ... > Isn't it, Stuart? ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: By the way...
    ... elle subit une forte opposition. ... geosciences and planetology. ... (Aren't you Stuart?) ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: Seismic waves, density and temperature.
    ... Bingham plastic do not behave like fluids in absence ... What do you think Stuart? ... convection in a Bingham plastic like material? ... way to go instead of a round Earth. ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: Owens Two-Phase Model of Earth Expansion
    ... Stuart wrote: ... If the Earth was steadily exapnding during this time, ... On what assumption is your expectation based, ... 'powerful' a driver than the internal heat below? ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
Quantcast