Re: PC vs Mac



Phil Yff wrote:
I attribute this trend to Apple's insular approach. They are more
interested in imposing a proprietary approach on development than they are
in attracting developers. They are spending a lot of energy on TV
commercials. Although the commercials correctly point out that Macs are
more stable, secure, and have better plug and play capabilities; they are
missing the point. It's all about software.

For the market that Apple is currently trying hardest to capture
(trendy young adults that now have a positive image of Apple because of
its iPod and iTunes product), it's not at all about the software. It's
about being cool, like the "Mac" guy in the commercials, and not being
like their dorky fathers, the "PC" guy in the commercials. Those
commercials are brilliant, and I'd bet doing far more to ship more Macs
than would have been acheived by pumping that ad budget into developer
support instead.

I disagree that applications sell computers. Mac software places very
few limitations on 95+% of users-- most just need to be able to perform
standard Internet-related tasks (surf, shop, check email, etc) and use
Office or an Office replacement for work or school. If anything the
cost of the systems is the biggest limiting factor.


This is not Apple bashing. The PC environment has its flaws, too,
especially in the area of security. However, I'm more concerned about the
Mac right now. I'm afraid it will fade away like Beta gave way to VHS.
The Macintosh will remain viable only if it can retain its user base and
you can't retain a user base without software apps.

You know that the Mac market share is increasing now, right? And that
most new shippped Macs can also run Windows XP?

From http://idc.com/getdoc.jsp?containerId=prUS20266906:

"Apple shipments increased by double digits in the second quarter
following a slow first quarter. Strong portable PC sales through its
retail outlets had a significant impact with retail growing by 50% and
portables by over 60% year on year. The strong growth reflects a
successful transition to Intel-based systems - a critical transition
for the company that sets the stage for future growth."

--Tony

.



Relevant Pages

  • Mac Mini?
    ... my last $2,500 for an early Macintosh computer after ... the commercials and magazine ads had all shown ... Mac screens with a lovely soft blue background but ... turned to IBM PC's (ah the irony of it, IBM instead of Apple had ...
    (comp.sys.mac.system)
  • Video: Apple Fails Miserably with new Mac vs. PC Ad
    ... Apple Fails Miserably with new Mac vs. PC Ad ... Here are are the latest 2 Mac vs PC ads. ... There's cute animation a la the 1964 Rudolph the Rednose Reindeer tv special, but I'm scratching my head as to why Apple would take such a departure from the standard Mac vs PC commercials by not touting ANY Mac benefits ... The first video, "I Can Do Anything" has absolutely nothing to do with computers. ...
    (comp.sys.mac.advocacy)
  • Re: So the Wintrolls dont believe Mac share is increasing...
    ... >> Mac" line of commercials. ... >> Apple stopped building Macs in 2006 and started building PCs ... "I'm a PC," and the other guy says "I'm a Mac," Apple must be saying the Mac is not a personal computer, according to you. ...
    (comp.sys.mac.advocacy)
  • Re: Apples newest commercials.
    ... Core Duo, ... I have also started reading the Mac ... Apple's commercials are stupid and continue to preach to the ... As long as Apple continues it's elitist snobbery appeal, ...
    (comp.sys.mac.advocacy)
  • Re: Microsoft continues to re-enforce Apple marketing messages
    ... Note that the commercial is structured so that the girl visits an Apple ... The obvious implication is that she'd have preferred a Mac, ... the message of these commercials seems to be "Sure, the Mac is better, ... Deep - very deep. ...
    (comp.sys.mac.advocacy)

Quantcast