Re: Indo-Aryan Migration in <<Several Waves>>
From: Researching (researching_at_not_here.com)
Date: 03/17/05
- Next message: Richard Herring: "Manx (was: Academic/scientific journals in Esperanto?)"
- Previous message: Jacques Guy: "Piraha apotheosis (and that is an understatement)"
- In reply to: Amit: "Re: Indo-Aryan Migration in <<Several Waves>>"
- Next in thread: o8TY: "Re: Indo-Aryan Migration in <<Several Waves>>"
- Reply: o8TY: "Re: Indo-Aryan Migration in <<Several Waves>>"
- Reply: o8TY: "Re: Indo-Aryan Migration in <<Several Waves>>"
- Reply: Amit: "Re: Indo-Aryan Migration in <<Several Waves>>"
- Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ]
Date: Thu, 17 Mar 2005 22:09:22 +1030
On 13 Mar 2005 22:15:44 -0800, ak2100@hotmail.com (Amit) wrote:
-snip-
>This is speculation at its best , Using the same similarities in
>Sanskrit and Avestan or some other ancient language it can be argues
>that migration was from east to west.
Language on its own does not prove one way or the other the direction
a migration went. Many other factors have to be considered.
The Aryan Invasion Theory and the Out of India Theory are both
conjecture and speculation.
>Serching genetical linage using
>mitochondrial DNA is more conclusive and scintific.
That depends, so far I have read three different interpretations of
the so-called data (which is supposed to be the same data) LOL.
I.E.:
1. It proves the Aryan invasion (or Aryan migrations took place) as
they entered India displacing the original Dravidians. The result a
genetic and cultural mixing.
2. Indians migrated outside of India spreading their languages.
Causing genetic dispersal and the grafting of various languages,
concepts and ideas.
3. Two way migrations, clashes, Trade etc took place (in the North)
which was more restricted in the South until later which caused a
genetic mixing and two way dispersal of ideas, words etc.
And so on.
-- Researching
- Next message: Richard Herring: "Manx (was: Academic/scientific journals in Esperanto?)"
- Previous message: Jacques Guy: "Piraha apotheosis (and that is an understatement)"
- In reply to: Amit: "Re: Indo-Aryan Migration in <<Several Waves>>"
- Next in thread: o8TY: "Re: Indo-Aryan Migration in <<Several Waves>>"
- Reply: o8TY: "Re: Indo-Aryan Migration in <<Several Waves>>"
- Reply: o8TY: "Re: Indo-Aryan Migration in <<Several Waves>>"
- Reply: Amit: "Re: Indo-Aryan Migration in <<Several Waves>>"
- Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ]
Relevant Pages
|
