Re: The Tally-Ho! Theory of Language Origins


rogerprince@xxxxxxxx wrote:
> Perhaps writing, in a sense, preceded spoken language.

....

> Evolution often makes new use of systems that have evolved for other
> purposes.

....

> Pure speculation, but traces of this route to language may be left in
> the human genome, `a la the genes that still code for hens' teeth and
> horses' toes.

This has the potential for a great argument about intelligent design.

The advocates for intelligent design might well have advanced speech as
an example of something so complicated and so efficient that it could
not possibly have evolved and therefore must have been handed to us as
a whole by the alleged intelligent designer. It's a better example than
any of the other examples I have seen.

But, so far as I know, they have not done so.

Maybe the reason is that we can PROVE that languages evolve.

But then I suppose we will have no argument because nobody on sci.lang
supports intelligent design.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: The Tally-Ho! Theory of Language Origins
    ... >> Perhaps writing, in a sense, preceded spoken language. ... >> Evolution often makes new use of systems that have evolved for other ... > This has the potential for a great argument about intelligent design. ... > Maybe the reason is that we can PROVE that languages evolve. ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Origin of Chinese spoken languages - 5th evidence
    ... >>and evolved from a writing system, called Hanja or Hanzi, and not vice ... >>system started with the spoken language first then a writing system ... >>have evolved from a written language. ... >>Chinese languages do not generate or evolve from a writing system, ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Evolution of Language
    ... Specifically, Nowak and colleagues' ... simulations have shown that the assembly of strings of meaningless ... elements into words is likely to evolve when there ... Regardless of its origins, acquisition or effects, language is ...
    (comp.ai.philosophy)
  • Re: Human brain on an evolutionary sprint!
    ... gets into with me will quickly evolve into an argument and I will win ... > I've not been following your posts, ... > You claimed to detect bullshit in Jim's ... >> language as we think we know it has failed ...
    (sci.anthropology.paleo)
  • Re: SCWC 32: Discussion: IMPLEMENT
    ... is ironically brought about by people consciously observing ... Also, in describing English "as she is spoke", since there ... I can understand that a language can evolve creatively, ... Games, too, evolve. ...
    (rec.puzzles.crosswords)