Re: Basque name formation?




John Atkinson wrote:

[...]

While I'm at it, her mother's surname, Malaga, doesn't seem to be Basque,
but rather comes from the city of the same name in the far south of Spain.
This even though "-aga" is a common ending for Basque place-names.
According to Wikipedia, it's Phoenician. They say: "The Phoenicians founded
the city Malaka here, in about 1000 BCE. The name Malaka is probably derived
from the Phoenician word for salt because fish was salted near the harbour;
in other Semitic languages the word for salt is still Hebrew מלח mélah. or
Arabic ملح milh. . [... Before the reconquista,] the city was called
Mālaqah (Arabic مالقة)."

Another slice of Wikibaloney, I'm afraid. One cannot arbitrarily alter
the triliteral {mlH} into {mlk} or {mlq}, so there is no way Malaca is
derived from 'salt'. The Wikiderivation is empty anyway. What ancient
seaport had _no_ fish-salting activities near the harbor?

The river was also the Malaca (now the Guadalmedina), so we have the
usual chicken-egg problem of hydrotoponyms. If the name is in fact
Phoenician, one possibility is a noun <mlqH> 'captured (place)' (cf.
Heb. <malqo(a)H> 'booty') from the triliteral {lqH} 'take, seize,
capture, etc.'. But that is only a late-night guess. If I had ready
access to a big library, I would look first in Menendez Pidal's
_Toponímia hispánica prerromana_, which may be an old book, but I
trust it more than an encyclopedia constructed by on-line anarchy.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Questions about Phoenician economy
    ... In 540 BC the Etruscans, with some Phoenician support, defeayed ... independent city ideally suited to act as the focus for the commerce of the ... As far as we an tell from the correspondence of the kings of Tyre ... and the birth of 'national' gods with no known predecents, like Melqart, ...
    (soc.history.ancient)
  • Port of second Carthage found Ancient Phoenician harbour discovered off Sardinian coast
    ... Ancient Phoenician harbour discovered off Sardinian coast ... Thursday they have found the port of the Phoenician city of Tharros, ... Sardinia, Cagliari, and the Sicilian capital Palermo. ...
    (sci.archaeology)
  • Re: OT ~ Global Warming Tour - See Climate Crisis
    ... No need to read the article, must be about Seattle's refusal to use salt on the roads. ... imagine a little salt doing in these fish with a little salt. ... This from a city with such poor sewer system that every time they get a decent rain, untreated sewage spills out into the river by the millions of gallons. ... When they get down to a point where they can turn around, and have stalled traffic for hrs, they move over to the other bound lanes and start doing the same. ...
    (rec.outdoors.rv-travel)
  • Re: Opinions please ...
    ... Salt Lk. ... City is most likely most reasonable due to cheapness of flts. ...
    (alt.gathering.rainbow)
  • Re: Opinions please ...
    ... it hurts like hell! ... Salt Lk. ... City is most likely most reasonable due to cheapness of flts. ...
    (alt.gathering.rainbow)