infinitive vs. -ing complements
- From: Keith GOERINGER <verbivore@xxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Sun, 18 Mar 2007 21:25:37 +0100
All,
Question for anyone, but input from non-native speakers of English, or
those who have taught English to non-native speakers, would be
particularly helpful.
My mother volunteers as an English tutor for the county, and has a
Chinese couple she's been working with for a few years now. The
exercise below threw them for a loop, and she was hard-pressed to
explain why some of the verbs could be followed with either an
infinitive or the -ing form, and why some could only have an infinitive
complement.
**********
Look at the verb that is given. Write the verb with to or -ing.
1. I avoided (tell) _________ my wife the truth.
2. One day Joyce tried (phone) _________________ me at work.
3. Little things began (annoy) ____________ me.
4. Last year, business began (slow) _____________ down.
6. Molly taught her (speak) _________________ English.
**********
My ad hoc analysis is that there is an aspectual distinction with 2-6.
2-4 seem to involve verbs that focus on the process, not the result, and
so either infinitive or -ing form (participle), whereas (6) focuses on
the result, so the infinitive is used. (1) is the odd man out, since it
seems that the sentence is -- by my analysis, and absent other
information -- relating a result, and so I would not expect a
participle. So I suggested that <avoid> subcategorizes for a
participle, and just needs to be learned as such. (I don't know where
(5) is -- it wasn't in what she sent me.)
But this is all the result of my looking at the sentences for about 5
minutes, and not doing any research. Any advice people have --
specifically in terms of something that could be used in the classroom,
to help non-native speakers grasp the distinctions -- would be
appreciated.
Cheers,
Keith
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: infinitive vs. -ing complements
- From: Nathan
- Re: infinitive vs. -ing complements
- From: Joe Fineman
- Re: infinitive vs. -ing complements
- Prev by Date: Re: Close-by r difficult?
- Next by Date: Re: Close-by r difficult?
- Previous by thread: fritillus frivolus
- Next by thread: Re: infinitive vs. -ing complements
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|