Re: Is language a mess?

Am 18 Apr 2007 11:33:39 -0700 schrieb Jens S. Larsen:

Joachim Pense:

Jens S. Larsen wrote:
written documents are to language what
footprints are to a foot. You may call a footprint a natural thing,
but it isn't part of the natural body who left it.

Both Written documents and recorded speaking are to language what footprints
are to a foot.

Writing and speaking are to language what walking is to a foot. Only
speaking is barefoot.

Writing is like walking with boots on, then. But using language is, in
this simile, like walking around, whether or not you are leaving
footprints on the way. It's only when you're leaving signs behind,
that you're enabling communication -- and most of the time when using
language, you don't leave signs behind. We all think many more words
than we say out loud or write.


I doubt that much linguistic research is or can be made about the
"inner monologue".

Joachim
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Is language a mess? (was: English is a mess.)
    ... footprints are to a foot. ... but it isn't part of the natural body who left it. ... Writing and speaking are to language what walking is to a foot. ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Is language a mess? (was: English is a mess.)
    ... footprints are to a foot. ... but it isn't part of the natural body who left it. ... Both Written documents and recorded speaking are to language what footprints ...
    (sci.lang)
  • NYTs take, including enlarged photo: Prints Show a Modern Foot in Prehumans
    ... Prints Show a Modern Foot in Prehumans ... that painted a picture of Homo erectus as the prehumans who took long ... The only earlier prints of a protohuman species ... said the footprints were further evidence that erectus had ...
    (sci.anthropology.paleo)
  • BBC: Earliest human footprints found
    ... Ileret footprint (M Bennett) ... The earliest footprints showing evidence of modern human foot anatomy ...
    (sci.anthropology.paleo)
  • Re: early Americans followed the sea
    ... >that shows a left and right footprint - the left footprint picture ... suggesting they were found left foot ahead of right ... Several types of animal prints were also identified including dogs, ... The researchers were able to classify the footprints as human ...
    (sci.anthropology.paleo)