Re: Waradpande seems to have destroyed PIE already

Franz Gnaedinger wrote:
On Dec 2, 3:38 pm, "Peter T. Daniels" <gramma...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
What is "definitionem"?

Typo. Per definitionem, by definition. A law can be
violated, per definitionem, by definition, otherwise
it weren't a law.

Please learn the meaning of "sound law."

Sound laws allow some reconstructions and forbid
others. Higher mathematical equations have more
than one solution, one must then choose the useful
one in the given context. Einstein's relativistic
equations have many solutions, among them freak
solutions, however, it turned out that one of the
freak solutions was a most valuable one, revealing
cosmic monsters called black holes. Now if the sound
laws of PIE hold, there are the traditional solutions
provided by comparative linguistics, and now there
is a new one, the Magdalenian solution. I prepared
a test case concerning words for wolf, differring
pointedly from the traditional PIE reconstruction;
apparently it is possible under the sound laws
of PIE, as nobody pointed out a violation of
one of those sound laws in my reconstruction.

Not receiving any objections does not mean that none exist and it certainly doesn't mean you are right.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: FTL causality problems. I dont get it.
    ... ruled out by a violation of a Bell's inequality (if I ever learn ... "new laws of physics", as in: given new laws of physics, current ... discovery would in fact require the possible discovery of new laws of ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Stop Interdimensional Meddling!
    ... Magic is the violation of logic, and if you're willing to have a ... If "the other side" obeys laws, then it can be studied scientifically, ... that is what we can observe. ... "top-down" communications and avatars, but no way for us to reach out ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: OT--just for John R. Mayne
    ... Copying an entire online article to make a point ... It is good to know that in the event that the New York Times decides to sue based on violation of copyright that it is the solons of RGB, well-versed as they are both in the written law and all the interpretations given in various courts throughout the almost two hundred nations of the Earth, who will sit in judgment of the case, no matter what the jurisdiction the New York Times company decides to bring the case in. ... It therefore behooves us to err on the side of caution and respect -- even over-respect -- for the copyright laws. ...
    (rec.games.bridge)
  • Re: Mexican media: Helms-Burton Unacceptable
    ... Mexico, Feb 5 The application here of the ... Helms-Burton Act against Cuba, in violation of Mexican law, is ... who stressed that the meeting had been ... But their presence did NOT violate US laws. ...
    (soc.culture.cuba)
  • Re: Wow ... Fox News really has no shame.
    ... Cooper's thus far unrefuted testimony suggests Rove may have violated ... but violation typically ... The key point above is that executive orders are not laws, ...
    (rec.sport.football.college)