Internalising new linguistic symbols and patterns



I read an interesting article in the Guardian Review at the weekend
describing something that often happens to me. The writer had been
Foreign Correspondent for somewhere like St. Petersburg and often
described the architecture there, including big statuesque figures
which form part of the columns or support of a building. Years later
he discovered the term for this -- caryatid. He writes,

"I felt a moment of foolishness which must be very old. Whoever
invented fire, I suspect, must have quickly lost ground to the man who
found a name for it."

I think this is very well put and describes something of the power of
words to capture complex ideas. Obscure words with precise meaning
risk confusing and alienating the reader, but if they absorb the
meaning (which they will do if they have a need for it) they may
discover that something they thought was complicated and ill-defined
or localised is covered by a much more general idea. I think the
Caryatid Effect is a nice name for this and, by virtue of the Caryatid
Effect, I'll think of it as that from now on :-)

What terms do linguists have for this, and can someone point me to
some lay-person's reading on what happens when symbolic patterns are
created in this way?

Something similar happens when programming, which is where my main
interest in it comes in. Programs should be written for future
readers; using an obscure but powerfully general idiom risks making
your program seem unclear but can provide the reader with an insight
into patterns he wasn't aware of. There's a tension between this and
the power and benefits of using the plainest "words" available, given
two "words" with the same meaning. The powerfully general idiom seems
like "plain speaking" to those who have internalised it, and like
baffling mumbo-jumbo to those who haven't. I don't know where the
tipping point between accessibility and dumbing-down lies.

Thanks,

Jim
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: what does "serialization" mean?
    ... language programming and found that my productivity increased to the ... the use of an expression in the For loop is not only ... acceptable it's good style because it forces the reader to understand. ... If the reader doesn't understand the language he must get ...
    (comp.programming)
  • Re: To Richard Heathfield: enoughs enough
    ... Hungarian notation, the identifiers are easier than non-Hungarian ... the SAME conscientiousness that uses Hungarian notation in the ... neither subject in any way to management whims and meaning ... there are in programming different discourse communities. ...
    (comp.programming)
  • Re: Worst SF/F book youve read
    ... > interpret into the text. ... "Intentional fallacy is a literary term that asserts that the meaning intended ... the reader to be intelligible at all. ...
    (rec.arts.sf.written)
  • Re: Narnia movie (was Re: Religion in SF)
    ... To the individual reader, ... That's sort of the point of reading, ... > But that "meaning" is just for him. ... mind to mind, but it very seldom succeeds perfectly. ...
    (rec.arts.sf.written)
  • Understanding descriptions
    ... State class descriptions are a neglected _part_ of AI development ... (including reinforcement learning type approaches to A(G)I ... such ideas to include in programming to describe components. ... class of positions that is meaning thousands or millions of positions, ...
    (comp.ai.philosophy)