Re: Linguistic superpowers or...



On Feb 1, 5:27 am, "jimbo.ty...@xxxxxxxxx" <jimbo.ty...@xxxxxxxxx>
wrote:
I found this link

http://strangemaps.wordpress.com/2008/01/02/230-papua-new-guinea-the-...

on nakedtranslations (a translator's blog). For people who don't
follow links it's a map purportedly showing countries ranked by
linguistic diversity. Here are the results for the top 12. I'm not
convinced by any of these numbers but the one that puzzles me is
Nigeria. Is there any evidence that Nigeria is more linguistically
diverse than its neighbours?

It's much bigger than its neighbours (more people), and it is
linguistically diverse, so it shouldn't be surprising that its
language total is large.

If you want more convincing, as Peter says, you can find these figures
(or very close to them) on Ethnologue, with full lists of the
languages, and maps. Ethnologue tends towards the "splitter" side. A
determined "lumper" might deflate their figures by 10 or even 20
percent, but I doubt more than that.

Ross Clark


Papua New Guinea 823 languages
Indonesia 726
Nigeria 505
India 387
Mexico 288
Cameroon 279
Australia 235
DR Congo 218
China 201
Brazil 192
United States 176
Philippines 169

.



Relevant Pages

  • Linguistic superpowers or...
    ... follow links it's a map purportedly showing countries ranked by ... linguistic diversity. ... Is there any evidence that Nigeria is more linguistically ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: The Linguistic Diversity of Aboriginal Europe
    ... The Linguistic Diversity of Aboriginal Europe: ... from substrate languages. ... even more iffy suggestion that the vowel system of Spanish derives in ... about completely vanished languages? ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Linguistic superpowers or...
    ... linguistic diversity. ... Is there any evidence that Nigeria is more linguistically ... The number for Indonesia looks grossly inflated ... 235 is a fair estimate of the number of languages that we know about that existed in Australia at the time of first contact. ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Linguistic superpowers or...
    ... follow links it's a map purportedly showing countries ranked by ... linguistic diversity. ...  Is there any evidence that Nigeria is more linguistically ... The number for Indonesia looks grossly inflated ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Linguistic superpowers or...
    ... linguistic diversity. ...  At least half those Indonesian languages are in West Papua, ... The last time I looked at the Ethnologue maps of Indonesia (on paper, ... the number of languages that we know about that existed in Australia at ...
    (sci.lang)