Re: Serbian - contemporary of Sanskrit

On Feb 15, 3:46 pm, fire.serpe...@xxxxxxxxx wrote:
On Feb 15, 1:14 pm, "Dušan Vukotić" <dusan.vuko...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:





On Feb 15, 12:37 pm, fire.serpe...@xxxxxxxxx wrote:

On Feb 15, 9:59 am, "Dušan Vukotić" <dusan.vuko...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Do you know the etymology of the Arabic word ssahhra (Sahara); is it
related to Arabic ssahha (cloudless. clear; Hebr. tsakh dry, glow,
dazzling, bright; Serb. suh dry; sijati glow, sjajan dazzling; Amharic
s'ähäy  sun)?

The primeval basis of all these words is Sur-Gon (Serb. Zor-njača
Venus; Sunce Sun; from Sur-Gon => sur-nke => sur-nce => sunce sun);
hence the Serbian words zrak (beam), zriknuti (look), Russian зеркало/
zerkalo (mirror); Serb. zrno (grain; according to the round shape of
the sun; sunce (sun; the omission of the sound r) <= surnce => zornica/
zornjača (Venus) => zrnce (grain). Now is clear that Serbian word suho
(dry) is derived from the noun sunce (sun) and the verb sunčati (to
sun); hence sušenje (drying; from suhenje /h => š palatalization/).

Sahara desert is nothing else but Serbian suhara (sušara /driying
place/) or Semitic sakh (dry; Serb. suh dry) and the relation between
the words sun (Arabic shams), sunny (shiny), Arabic ssahha (clear;
Hebrew tzakh dry, bright) and Serbian suh (dry) and sjajan (shiny;
also Serb. sinuti brighten) is more than obvious.

Finally, if we compare Arabic sahhar (dawn) and Serbian zora (dawn) we
will understand that any story about "mother" language is pointless;
cf. feminine personal name Zuhra, Zorah (dawn) and Serbian Zora/Zorica
(dawn); Zohreh (planet Venus; Serb. Zornjača Venus).

DV

You know what? This conversation is pointless, because you will first
need to acquire thorough knowledge of semitic.

In other words, this "conversation is pointless unless you accept my
doctrine".
;-)

Sahraa - derived from the root S-H-R - could NEVER be derived from a
word like sušara or suh, because these letters cannot be added to or
subtracted from a root to form another root in Arabic. S-H-R can never
come from s-š-r or s-h. Sounds simply cannot and do not change in
Arabic roots.

I did not say that Sahra is derived from any IE word.

Although I understand that you are trying to apply IE derivation to
Arabic because that is the only method you seem to know, what you are
demonstrating here is that you have no understanding whatsoever of how
roots function in Arabic in particular and semitic in general.

If you did not see I used the basis Sur-Hor (it is from my Xur-Bel-Gon
Theory; Human Speech Formula) and it is quite different from PIE
reconstruction. I am not saying that Semitic is "derived" from IE
while you are trying to suggest that IE is a "child" of Semitic. My
opinion is that both of these two families were born from the same
source (Xur-Bel-Gon).

Comparing Sahraa to Zohraa is also a clear example of how you do not
understand that s and z are NOT interchangeable in Arabic. In Arabic
NO consonants are interchangeable. They ARE interchangeable in IE.

Not truth! Compare sharq (East), sahhar (dawn) and Zuhara (Venus),
Sanskrit śukra (Venus);
Or gharb (West), gharib (foreigner), harb (war), harb (hostility);
gharib (camel's back); ghariba (go dawn, sunset)
Arabic sachuna (be warm) is clearly related to Serbian suh, sunčanje,
sušenje and sunce (the sun), Arabic shams (the sun)

Do not confuse apples with oranges please!

Therefore, like I said before, please go and learn Arabic thoroughly
before you attempt to apply IE models to this ancient language

Once again, where did you see that I tried to apply any "IE
model" (whatever you regard as "IE model")? The reality is quite the
opposite, you are trying to impose your theory about alleged "Arabic
origin of IE". Read your words above (the last paragraph) and you will
see that only Arabic is an "ancient language".

DV

Your examples are, I am afraid, pure fantasy. Whatever model you are
applying just does not work with Arabic.

I rest my case.

Like I said, learn Arabic. It will benefit you.

Bye, DV

Bye Serpent, bye!
I believed it would be easy for you to demonstrate that my above
examples were wrong. Instead of showing your extraordinary knowledge
of Arabic, you decided to run away without "paying the bill"!
Unfortunately, you missed another chance to prove that Arabic is the
ANCESTOR of all the other languages in the world.
What a pity!

DV


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Serbian - contemporary of Sanskrit
    ... dazzling, bright; Serb. ... suh dry; sijati glow, sjajan dazzling; Amharic ... the words sun, sunny, Arabic ssahha (clear; ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Serbian - contemporary of Sanskrit
    ... dazzling, bright; Serb. ... suh dry; sijati glow, sjajan dazzling; Amharic ... the words sun, sunny, Arabic ssahha (clear; ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Serbian - contemporary of Sanskrit
    ... dazzling, bright; Serb. ... suh dry; sijati glow, sjajan dazzling; Amharic ... subtracted from a root to form another root in Arabic. ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Serbian - contemporary of Sanskrit
    ... suh dry; sijati glow, sjajan dazzling; Amharic ... The primeval basis of all these words is Sur-Gon (Serb. ... subtracted from a root to form another root in Arabic. ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Serbian - contemporary of Sanskrit
    ... suh dry; sijati glow, sjajan dazzling; Amharic ... The primeval basis of all these words is Sur-Gon (Serb. ... if we compare Arabic sahhar (dawn) and Serbian zora we ...
    (sci.lang)