Re: FGC to Grapheus
- From: "grapheus@xxxxxxx" <grapheus@xxxxxxx>
- Date: Thu, 24 Jul 2008 11:48:24 -0700 (PDT)
On Jul 24, 8:30 pm, altero.pol...@xxxxxxxxx wrote:
Dearest Grapheus,
excuse my delayed replay, please (familiar occupations during the last
week end and the following days).
A part last days discussions... I have to pose you another little
difficulty I have (pardon my rough locutions): I read scholars try to
interpretate Linear A Signs on the base of Linear B correspondants or
expressions (e.g.: potokuro); otherwise sometimes I found you cannot
found your assumptions on Phaestos Disk starting from the same Linear
B (signs/expressions). It seems to me a strange logical proceeding
when it's based on uncertain time's (linguistical evolution ?)
succession.
More and better: it's possible you can separate (and abstract from)
probable/unsure sign's signifiance from sign's (probable/unsure,
syllabic or not) sound? I mean: can you (easily, opportunistically:
when you need) adjust your interpretation without a constant
"converting" method?
I hope I was able to present my mind in a quite comprehensible way...
else...
Furthermore, about "my interpretations", you can have, obviously by
combinations, many of them.
Thank's the same when you reject all my absurdities.
FGC
If I understan correctly your question, you are asking me : "Why the
Phaistos Disk is NOT related in one way or the other to the LinearA/
B ?"..
Well, the answer is easy : The "Civilization of the Disk" IS NOT
"Minoan". Lnear A and B, as are also the Cypriot Syllabic Scripts,
HAVE A MINOAN ORIGIN. NOT the Disk !.. The Disk belongs to a DIFFERENT
Civilization, Greek yes, but NOT "Mycenaean"... This is easily
explained by the "Reconstruction of the Prehistory of the Greeks" :
the "Greek ethnic Group" was born South of Danube from the mixing of
local populations with "Indoeuropeans" who came from South Russia (M.
Gimbutas' theory). This Greek Ethnic Group moved South in three
"Waves" : the "Proto-Ionic" one came by sea c. 3000 to the Cyclades,
and later (c. 250OBC) to Euboea and Attic -- the "Achaeans/Mycenaeans"
came by land c. 2100BC -- as for the "Dorian wave", archaeologists
don't agree about the date. But they agree that the went first to the
West of Greece. So, their LANGUAGE was the same : Greek. But their
"Cultures" (in particular Script) were somewhat different...
Regards
grapheus
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: FGC to Grapheus
- From: grapheus@xxxxxxx
- Re: FGC to Grapheus
- References:
- FGC to Grapheus
- From: altero . polini
- FGC to Grapheus
- Prev by Date: Re: Arabic word for fat
- Next by Date: Re: Minerva-paper on the Phaistos Disk : The main argument
- Previous by thread: FGC to Grapheus
- Next by thread: Re: FGC to Grapheus
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|
