Re: proof that most etymologies are only fairy-tales

Franz Gnaedinger wrote:
On Aug 11, 2:14 pm, Harlan Messinger
<hmessinger.removet...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
"Experiment", for you, means "it came into my mind and I've decided
everything that comes into my mind is true". Unfortunately, that isn't
what "experiment" means. It *is* what the word "fantasy" means. But
"fantasy" != "science".

You are lying.

How am I lying, when this characterizes your own description of your so-called "experiments"?

In 1995 I published my first two
Magdalenian laws, in 1996 I published my
third and fourth Magdalenian laws, and then
I mined Magdalenian permutation groups
using my four Magdalenian laws. Among those
permutation groups is the one of BRI from the
summer of 2007, as I recall, and it contains
BIR meaning fur, especially the fur where
a newborn was laid on. You can check this
either in my etymological thread or in my online
Magdalenian dictionary.

Are you under the impression that your fantasies become the truth just because you've created an "online Magdalenian dictionary"?

Now I am using the
words in my dictionary to explain words like
bear. My explanation is obviously very good,
in fact so good that you must snip most of
what I say.

I snipped it because I wasn't addressing it and unlike some of the folks here who keep endless threads in each and every follow-up posting, I trim mine so people don't have to spend all their time scrolling over stuff they've already read.

I don't consider PIE fairy tales,

PIE wasn't made up by one person making stuff up in his head, calling it an "experiment", and decreeing it to be the truth just because it appealed to him.
.