Re: observable language change - "off of" makes it to the NY Times

On Aug 11, 5:42 pm, "benli...@xxxxxxxxxx" <benli...@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Aug 12, 8:05 am, analys...@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:





On Aug 11, 3:04 pm, Adam Funk <a24...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

On 2008-08-10, Brian M. Scott wrote:

On Sun, 10 Aug 2008 07:18:29 -0700 (PDT),
<analys...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in
<news:47020cff-57cc-4340-9bd7-2956455923af@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
in sci.lang:

start quote:

Overnight, Russia landed ground troops off of warships
into the disputed territory of Abkhazia and broadened its
bombing campaign to the Georgian capital’s airport.

end quote.

Whats next - "I'm like" for "I said" ?

Different category altogether.  See, for instance,
<http://www.wsu.edu/~brians/errors/nonerrors.html> (search
for 'off of').

I agree with you.  There are plenty of other "compound prepositions"
in English: "He came down from the top of the hill while we were
walking up to it."

Of course, "off of" doesn't seem to add any information in comparison
with "off", but I'm not convinced that's much of an objection to
adding just one syllable or two letters.

--
Bob just used 'canonical' in the canonical way.  [Guy Steele]- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

Would you use it serious writing?

Why not? You still haven't explained why it's "dumb".

You are obviously posturing (have you ever used it in serious
writing?) It is just slovenly speech and inexcusable writing.



There cannot be a shadow of a doubt that the NY Times has started
using it to make its bourgeoise readers feel at home, who it thinks

"bourgeoise"?? You really ought to check a dictionary, for both
spelling and meaning.


Sad.

would be put off by too strict an adherence to the rules of proper
usage and therefore occasional "down home" expressions like this would
be a good marketing ploy.

"down home"?? Try to avoid using terms like this that just make you
look silly.


It is a scientific socio-linguistic observation - how a journalistic
product is changing to keep up with the linguistic changes (it thinks
is) going on among it target audience.



http://cjrarchives.org/tools/lc/fused.asp

says

start quote:

(And while in technical land, we should note that "off of" is a
barbarism; drop the "of.")

end quote.

So you found some journalist who shares your prejudice and thinks
"barbarism" makes him sound learned.
You still haven't explained what's wrong with "off of".

I am sure you understand what 'drop the 'of'' means. And what makes
the redundancy worse is the unintended rhyme.

Here is what the online dictionary says

start quote:

Usage Note: The compound preposition off of is generally regarded as
informal and is best avoided in formal speech and writing: He stepped
off (not off of) the platform. Off is informal as well when used to
indicate a source: formal style requires I borrowed it from (not off)
my brother.

end quote.




At any rate "off of" has a legitimate use

"In a war characterised by such atrocities as the hacking off of
civilians’ limbs and the widespread use of rape to"

That's not "off of" anyway, so it's not a "use" of anything.

Genuine "off of" is attested from the 15th century on.

Where?

King James Bible? Shakespeare? MIlton?




While "where are you at" is equally inapporpriate, somehow it is cute
whereas "off of" is preternaturally annoying.

I'm sure you could regale us with a recital of your likes and dislikes
all day long. Some might find this cute, and some annoying. But unless
you can explain rationally what's wrong with "off of", take it to
a.u.e.

This is sad also.


Ross Clark- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

.

Relevant Pages

  • Playing By Markies Rules and He Still Cant Stand It
    ... > cuting stevie liblinga man he has never met ... QUOTE: ... I said "IF" his/her writing can't be read... ... Sorry Markie, but such modifiers are YOUR argument as to why YOU ...
    (rec.radio.amateur.policy)
  • Re: Schechner - This is for you Farrow
    ... So he happens to be reading for his anthropology class and he comes across the following quote from Schechner, ... when Mr. Farrow was telling me I should read some Schechner in order to understand his argument for not messing with "classics" I wonder what he meant? ... What I meant was that your definition of what can constitute a "performance", as you laid it out in that thread, needed some updating because it was too simplistic (particularly your statement about literature not being a performative art, since writing is very definitely an act of performance - when you write, you are using words to perform a representation of yourself and your ideas). ... argument by using a single, simple sentence excerpted from a much longer, much more complex theoretical work, and that it's dangerous - and suggestive of a lack of critical thinking on your part - to quote anything by a single academic theorist as an unassailable truth. ...
    (rec.arts.theatre.musicals)
  • Re: hiring someone to quilt
    ... The first time I sent a quilt out to be quilted, ... The quilter took much longer to ... quote in writing, but there was nothing I could do at that point. ...
    (rec.crafts.textiles.quilting)
  • Re: OT Soffits and Facias
    ... A guy from Virgo Home Improvements came tonight and quoted £9,800 ... Ask for a quote of the price in writing. ...
    (uk.media.tv.misc)