Re: Jesus multiplying bread and fish

On Oct 21, 9:19 am, Franz Gnaedinger <f...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Oct 21, 2:29 pm, "Peter T. Daniels" <gramma...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:



Then "your book" is thirty years old. When Eblaite was first
discovered, certain enthusiasts jumped on its geographic location and
assumed that it had to be an ancestor or close relative of Northwest
Semitic, but before the end of the 1970s its true affiliation was
known. See Manfred Krebernik in the Albright Centennial conference
volume, and even before that, Gelb, "Ebla and the Kish
Civilization" (1978).

The opinions about Eblaitic are divided. Some consider

No, they are not. No, they do not.

it West Semitic, others East Semitic. Cyrus H. Gordon
called it a boardercase language with leanings in both

He turned out to be wrong.

directions. Considering the location and history of Ebla
- in the west, autonomous until taken by Naramsin of
Akkad - I assume the original language was West Semitic,

Once again, your assumption is asinine.

while the East Semitic elements were acquired during
the Akkadian period. Akkad was by then the most modern
nation, inevitable that their language sipped in.

Place names don't identify a language!
Is this one of your fantasies? Where is this name written that way?

How many times did I tell you about Linear A tablet
Hagia Triada 95? Minuthe is found there, and on

No idea. I don't usually look beyond your first few lines, when you
start raving about "Magdalenian."

several other Linear A tablets, and it is written
the same way on hieroglyphic tablets, and in
Linear B: head of a bull (mi) visual pun of a bull
leaper standing on the feet hands feet (nu) tree of
life (the). My question is about munutium mnt minnit
Minuthe in Ebla: was it a place in the surroundings
of Ebla? or was it an Old Ebla, a former palace or
bulwark on the limestone hill? The dwellers of that
place would have left munutium mnt minnit Minuthe
in 2800 BC or even earlier, perhaps in 3000 BC,
and traveled and sailed to Crete, out of whatever
reason.

Cyrus Gordon never showed to anyone else's satisfaction that Linear A
or any of the other fragmentary scripts he claimed to have deciphered
were Northwest Semitic.

Jan Best followed Gordon, some others too,

Next you're going to bring up von Daniken again.

and then Walther Hinz succeeded in translating
Linear A tablet Hagia Triada 95, see my thread
"Linear A tablet Hagia Triada 95" from several
years ago. Hinz proved Gordon correct.

Not to anyone else's satisfaction.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Jesus multiplying bread and fish
    ... Considering the location and history of Ebla ... How many times did I tell you about Linear A tablet ... Linear A tablet Hagia Triada 95, ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Jesus multiplying bread and fish
    ... assumed that it had to be an ancestor or close relative of Northwest ... Linear B: head of a bull visual pun of a bull ... Minuthe in Ebla: was it a place in the surroundings ... Linear A tablet Hagia Triada 95, ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Jesus multiplying bread and fish
    ... of Linear A tablet Hagia Triada 95. ... The Eblaite texts were ... no place in my life. ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Jesus multiplying bread and fish
    ... My book says the people of Ebla spoke ... a _West_ Semitic language and Sumerian. ... Linear A tablet Hagia ... way in hieroglyphic Minoan, in Linear A ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Acheaology of Ebla, links to Abram?
    ... > Thus the connection between Abram and Ebla is possible. ... > reference to it may have been coded possibly reference to the city of ... succeeded in translating the Linear A tablet Hagia Triada ... the head of a bull, a man leaping from his feet on ...
    (sci.archaeology)