Re: Hello There?


"Torkel Franzen" <torkel@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:vcb8y1q4b8t.fsf@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> Robert Low <mtx014@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> writes:
>
>> And didn't Carl Sagan write a bizarre
>> novel in which a circle encoded into
>> the digits of pi was proof of the
>> existence of God?
>
> There was some kind of message encoded in pi in the
> book. Unfortunately, this nonsensical idea was not taken up in the
> movie version.
>
>


I loved the idea. It certainly made me think of the limits of omnipotence -
can God make arithmetic work differently? Not a concept aften discussed in
airport thrillers.

It also had a nice context, in that she (the astronomer) originally received
a message from the aliens by radio; they advised her to look for another
message in the base 11 representation of pi - just a different
communications medium.

BTW, if you thought it was nonsensical why are you diappointed they didn't
have it in the movie (which I didn't see)?



.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Fantasy Cliche: Perfect Rationalists
    ... >> every possible message should be in the digits. ... > are arranged in a square, they form an image of a circle. ... even as I've only seen the movie ... > including pi, contain, not just the full ASCII text of that novel, ...
    (rec.arts.sf.fandom)
  • Re: OT: What movies have you seen recently?
    ... >>> Read the story by Annie Proulx. ... Because it was - whether as a short story, a novel, or a Hollywood ... The reason I went to see the movie is because I read all the reviews. ... me it would've been better if we saw more of the other characters. ...
    (alt.fashion)
  • Re: "Can a Machine Think?" Judges Needed for Loebner Prize 2005
    ... >>>Did you know that Sagan was a believer in time travel? ... >extremely disgusted with the hollywood movie starring Jodie ... >characters says "98% of people in the world beleive in a God... ... >MODERN chinese civilization never had a god in their religion. ...
    (comp.ai.philosophy)
  • Re: With God on Our Sides relevance
    ... scenes of recent American history come alive, ... Thanks for bringing this up (the movie, ... startling of all, for me, was to hear the original With God on Our Side ... who was the man descending in the "American poison ivy ...
    (rec.music.dylan)
  • Re: A couple of queries for Friends and Interested persons
    ... God dictating his will. ... A dear friend once the story of the time she was having a spiritual crisis, ... She didn't care what movie it ... Brother Bear is absolutely not the sort of movie she would otherwise pay to ...
    (soc.religion.quaker)