Re: Penrose vs the Robot


Daryl McCullough wrote:
> The problem is that what is r.e. is the set of possible
> *behaviors* of the robot. We don't have a foolproof means
> of determining what "unassailable beliefs" are implied
> by that behavior. So we can't go from an r.e. set of
> behaviors to an r.e. set of "unassailable beliefs".
>
> Or, at least I don't see any way to extract the set of
> unassailable beliefs from the robot's program. Without
> such an extraction procedure, Penrose' argument can't
> even get started.
>

Penrose's suggestion was that the robot could prefix a star to those
sentences it believed unassailably. Are you suggesting there might be
things the robot unassailably believes but doesn't prefix a star to?

> --
> Daryl McCullough
> Ithaca, NY

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Where is behavior AI now?
    ... what can be put in it is also limited (given hardware suite remains the ... We can know if we have addressed all the robot ... and one motor. ... Can we construct a finite set of behaviors for this ...
    (comp.robotics.misc)
  • Re: Where is behavior AI now?
    ... distinctively more intelligent than when the robot is driving itself, ... same two output motors in both cases. ... without the controller, that you can with the control, too, right? ... quantifiably different output combinations as atomic behaviors. ...
    (comp.robotics.misc)
  • Re: Where is behavior AI now?
    ... distinctively more intelligent than when the robot is driving itself, ... same two output motors in both cases. ... without the controller, that you can with the control, too, right? ... quantifiably different output combinations as atomic behaviors. ...
    (comp.robotics.misc)
  • Re: Where is behavior AI now?
    ... So here's the route I was coming this time. ... Say you have a simple robot. ... Yes there are stall sensors, but they don't measure the world, they ... How many different behaviors can jBot have? ...
    (comp.robotics.misc)
  • Re: Where is behavior AI now?
    ... last input, we now have 4 binary inputs to trigger behaviors with, which ... The more historic sensory data we record, ... our output behaviors, the more complex, and the more "intelligent" our ... the robot can respond to being caught in a corner by ...
    (comp.robotics.misc)
Loading