Re: Horn clause question..



theunlearnedone wrote:
I was just reading up about horn clause. As per my understanding Horn
clause is a clause with at most one positive literal.No other
conditions are required so I am unable to understand the following
statements associated with Horn clause:

~a1 | ~a2 ... ~ an | b can be written equivalently as

a1 & a2 & ... an -> b

I am unable to reason such an implication. all of a1, ... an and 'b'
can be independent literals so either material or logical implication
can only be incidental, and not a given. What am I not seeing/reading
that will make sense of the implied implication (pun unintended).

In Propositional and Predicate Logic you have the equivalence of A -> B
with ~A | B (either the premise is false or the conclusion needs to be
true). So if you have a conjunction of premises, you can just apply De
Morgan's laws: (A1 & ... & An) -> B is equivalent to ~(A1 & ... & An) |
B is equivalent to ~A1 | ... | ~An | B . For example: A1 = "It's
raining.", A2="I don't have a raincoat." B="I don't leave the house." so
A1 & A2 -> B means "If it's raining and I don't have raincoat, I don't
leave the house". You know only what I will do, if the conditions are
met - otherwise everything is admissible (even that I leave the house
anyway - but you can't expect that).

This left the philosophical point of view a bit on the side - I thought
I'd explain it fastest this way.

hth, Martin
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: R^R = R^2 = R
    ... ZFC without CH. ... Since the "if" clause is false, it follows that the implication is ... vacuously true. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: R^R = R^2 = R
    ... The "if" clause is not satisfied in ZF, which is the set theory that I ... Clearly, the implication is false. ... Your response too. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Covenant in lease specifying insurance co - status ?
    ... there's a clause in my lease which states that the ... How enforceable is this clause, and if it is, how reasonable is ... enables them to argue that they need to check that the insurer you ... The property the op was talking about is a house not a flat so ...
    (uk.legal)
  • Re: Marry a Jew or be disinherited...
    ... I know a Jewish woman who owns a house that is so old ... company will want an affirmative statement from a court that such a clause ... I believe Maryland (where Susan resides, so I'm assuming that's where the ... grumble) years ago in Property class. ...
    (soc.culture.jewish.moderated)
  • Re: Permutations in Prolog
    ... >I'm working on a program which traces a route from any house (I'll ... >the island and then back to ... >certain points - I've put these in a clause down below. ... >It's a bit like the travelling salesman problem I think. ...
    (comp.lang.prolog)