Re: A free copy of Maple or a frre maple webservre

"Peter Pein" <petsie@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote

... to determine if that international journal considered Sage
to be verified. ...

Do you want to imply: there exists a CAS xyz with the property: "xyz is
considerd to be verified" ?

LOL,
Peter

No I do not. I have no idea if reviewers for international journals consider
any computer algebra system to be verified. The only knowledge that I can
offer is that reviewers of one nuclear journal have access to, and use some
kinds of CAS ( I do not know what they use). I base this knowledge on my
observation that they have the ability to take mathematical expressions
provided to them in print form (or in Equation Editor MS Word documents) and
check and improve upon them. Given the difficulty in computation this likely
was done by using some CAS that they consider trustworthy.

I may have misspoken above so let me expand. I specifically cited Maple in
my list of references in my submission. The amount of CPU time that I
expended on Maple symbolic manipulation in my work amounted to several weeks
of CPU time in aggregate. After much travail I obtained simplification that
were meaningful. I do not think the reviewers would have put that amount of
effort into verifying the final results. They verified my own
trustworthiness and given that Maple was cited and provided meaningful
simplifications they decided that the results were sufficiently trustworthy
to convey to readers.

I consider Maple to be verified as far as my own work is concerned. My
experience with one scientific journal suggests that they consider Maple to
be verified as far as my own work is concerned. I have no idea if this would
work with Sage but you are welcome to try.

2


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Computer Algebra Algorithms
    ... If you want to learn CAS, learn lisp because that is what the open ... You could then perform some algebra on ... In this case you may not care if you can overload the plus ... would suggest learning the external function interface of MAPLE. ...
    (sci.math.symbolic)
  • Re: Guter 3D Function Plotter gesucht
    ... Wenn du die Möglichkeit hast günstige Studenten- oder Schullizenzen zu ... CAS zu werfen: Maple,Mathematica,Mupad ... dass Mathematica mit Version 6 eine komplett neue ... Maple ...
    (de.sci.mathematik)
  • Re: GPL vs LGPL vs CAS
    ... perspective of CAS would not add much to the discussion. ... the source code of the algorithms in a CAS ... Because the US funding agencies do not see system building ... to Maple. ...
    (sci.math.symbolic)
  • Re: Compute eigen values/vectors of a 22k x 22k matrix
    ... Any CAS program (for example Maple, Mathematica, or Maxima) should be ...
    (sci.math)