Re: Surrogate factoring, complete theory

From: Tim Peters (tim.one_at_comcast.net)
Date: 03/07/05


Date: Sun, 6 Mar 2005 19:11:52 -0500


[JSH]
>>>>> [...]
>>>>> so that
>>>>>
>>>>> x = zr
>>>>>
>>>>> where r is a prime factor of M,
>>>>> [...]
>>>>> assume that r = n/d, where n and d are coprime integers,
>>>>> [...]
>>>>> The problem now is, how do you get d?

[Tim Peters]
>>>> If r is a prime, and r = n/d where gcd(n, d)=1, then the only
>>>> solutions are n=+/-r and d=+/-1.

[JSH]
>>> Hmmm...where did you get that?

[Tim explains]

[JSH]
> Oh, you're still trying r an integer,

Given your "where r is a prime factor of M" quoted above, and my "If r is a
prime" rephrasing of that, ya, of course r is an integer.

> but r can't always be an integer.
>
> That's been the point of all this effort today.

I agree r isn't always an integer. I just started replying in the order
msgs showed up here; at the time I replied, "where r is a prime factor of M"
was in the msg I was replying to.

> ...
> It still might be that even j is the problem, yet again, despite my
> efforts to allow even j. We'll see...

It might even be that there's no exploitable relationship to factors of T; I
confess that I haven't seen a reason to suspect that there must be one.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Surrogate Factoring Theorem
    ... [Tim Peters, expressing affection for James] ... >> Why do you waste time typing all this social crap? ... pretty lame if that were the _only_ reason; I was hoping in addition to get, ... I'm not sure you've read every reply JSH has given me over these months. ...
    (sci.crypt)
  • Re: Surrogate Factoring Theorem
    ... [Tim Peters] ... For that matter, I'm not sure I have either. ... character assassination in return for my effort (but in tangential threads, ... Suppose it's possible that JSH is hiding knowledge of a sixth ...
    (sci.crypt)
  • Re: Still hoping?
    ... [Tim Peters, to JSH] ... >> Fine by me, although you already pretend to ignore most of them, so ... >> actually work if I hadn't done large blobs of basic work for you. ... > JSH invariably turns against and abuses anyone who tries to help him. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Surrogate factoring, complete theory
    ... [JSH] ... [Tim Peters] ... I just started replying in the order ... msgs showed up here; at the time I replied, "where r is a prime factor of M" ...
    (sci.crypt)
  • Re: Factoring problem, solved
    ... >> Stop replying to JSH already!!! ... It is a good way to deal with such a JSR - JSH is ... faulty and he has been just about equally faulty in all his post. ...
    (sci.crypt)