Re: a ESP test (statistical problem)



riparian wrote:
A ESP test (extra sensory perception) is carried like this:
From a deck of cards were chosen 5 cards. These cards were seen by both the conductor of the experiment and a person. The cards were laid on the table with the back side upwards in such a way that only the conductor of the experiment knew the sequence of the cards. The conductor chosed a card and the person should then say which card it was. In a sequence of 100 experiments the person answered correctly 37 times.
Is there reason to believe that this person has special supernatural powers?



Hi riparian,

I would say it's easy to simulate. All the experiments seem to be "unconditioned", that is, it seems that the experiment person has a 1/5 Probability each time of success.

try to simulate it with MATLAB, for example, in order to get always a '1' in each experiment (supposing that this is the card which the conducer takes).

I think 37/100 it's a high probability but not necessary to high. It must be checked with real simulation. Only results clearly above these simulations would show special powers which can control the chaos of the probability.

  Greetings, Pablo


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: a ESP test (statistical problem)
    ... >>From a deck of cards were chosen 5 cards. ... >conductor of the experiment and a person. ... There are other non-supernatural explanations, ...
    (sci.math)
  • a ESP test (statistical problem)
    ... >From a deck of cards were chosen 5 cards. ... conductor of the experiment and a person. ... experiment knew the sequence of the cards. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: a ESP test (statistical problem)
    ... > deck of cards were chosen 5 cards. ... > conductor of the experiment knew the sequence of the cards. ... designed to rule out non-supernatural means of obtaining information. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: a ESP test (statistical problem)
    ... >> From a deck of cards were chosen 5 cards. ... >> conductor of the experiment and a person. ... >> experiment knew the sequence of the cards. ... >A Blind Monkey would make at least 20 out of 100. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: what are the odds of....
    ... The probability Pof getting a straight flush with suited connectors ... is the probability that you hit one of four combinations of cards by the ...
    (rec.gambling.poker)