Re: what makes it true?

In article <slrndhkgbv.to4.tim-usenet@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
Timothy Little <tim-usenet@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> writes:
>mareg@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx () wrote:
>> Virtually everybody, irrespective of their philosophical or
>> religious views, believes that Goldbach's conjecture is either true
>> or false, even though it has not yet been proved which, and
>> conceivably never will be.
>
>Virtually everybody, irrespective of their philosophical or religious
>views, believes that the Continuum Hypothesis is either true or false,
>even though it has not yet been proved which, and conceivably never
>will be.

Judging from personal experience, I don't believe that to be true.
My impression is that virtually everybody believes that Goldbach's
conjecture is either true or false, but it is definitely not the case
that virtually everybody believes that the Continuum Hypothesis is
either true or false. Given that neither CH not not CH can be deduced
from the other axioms of set theory, this is not surprising! It is
doubtful whether the notions of "true" and "false" can meaningfully
be attached to the Continuum Hypothesis.

Derek Holt.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: what makes it true?
    ... >> Timothy Little wrote: ... >>> views, believes that the Continuum Hypothesis is either true or false, ... >> and so far found true by number crunching. ... would fall in the same class as Goldbach's conjecture. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: what makes it true?
    ... religious views, believes that Goldbach's conjecture is either true or false, even though it has not yet been proved which, and conceivably never will be. ... But someting like that obviously cannot be accomplished for the Continuum Hypothesis. ... Is it anything more than another consequence of the over-generalizations inherent in standard Set Theory? ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: what makes it true?
    ... believes that Goldbach's conjecture is either true ... views, believes that the Continuum Hypothesis is either true or false, ... Prev by Date: ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: why does professor david c ullrich have to put people down to feel good about himself?
    ... Here's a new claim, based on tommy1729's conjecture. ... going to do anything that standard set theory does. ... David C. Ullrich ... "Understanding Godel isn't about following his formal ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Conjecture in "Mathematical Cranks"
    ... Dudley comments that he would bet that the conjecture is false. ... surprised to find a counterexample. ... It certainly would be surprising if the conjecture is false. ...
    (sci.math)