Re: obtaining notes on classic textbooks
- From: matthias@xxxxxxxxxxx
- Date: 14 Feb 2006 09:37:27 -0800
Dani wrote:
For me, the solutions are used to check my own solutions.
Suppose that you write a proof for some problem, and then you open the
solutions manual and find a completely different proof. How does that
help you tell whether your proof is correct?
The problems in advanced math textbooks aren't algebra problems where
the answer is a number; they are problems where a single answer, fully
written out, might be three pages once typeset. So to write down
answers to all the problems, you essentially have to write a book worth
of advanced mathematics, but the book is not original research because
the problems have already been solved by someone else. Few people who
are able to solve all the problems feel that writing such a book is a
valuable way to spend their time.
I'm sorry to be the one to tell you, but there really just aren't long
documents with all the answers to classic textbooks. The best you
could hope for is to get (handwritten) notes from a very careful former
student who has worked through the problems.
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: obtaining notes on classic textbooks
- From: Wayne Brown
- Re: obtaining notes on classic textbooks
- References:
- obtaining notes on classic textbooks
- From: Dani
- Re: obtaining notes on classic textbooks
- From: matthias
- Re: obtaining notes on classic textbooks
- From: Dani
- obtaining notes on classic textbooks
- Prev by Date: Re: Why do they teach Riemannian sums?
- Next by Date: Re: Poll - are you a platonist?
- Previous by thread: Re: obtaining notes on classic textbooks
- Next by thread: Re: obtaining notes on classic textbooks
- Index(es):