Re: famous conjecture / former conjecture



In article <1139953269.905828.9320@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
pauldepstein@xxxxxxx writes:
Sorry, I know there's a similar question which makes a hard (or even
unsolved) problem. I should have said: Suppose all countable
subgroups of G are free, is G free?


I don't know the answer, and it may well be unknown. I was wondering
whether the fundamental group of the Hawaiian Earring is a candidate.
This is an uncountable group that is locally free but not free. There is
a lot of literature on this group, and I had a quick look through some
of the papers, but I could not find any direct reference to the question
of whether or all countable subgroups are free.

Derek Holt.
a quick look at
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Relations in GL(n,C)
    ... I am wondering if there is any sort of algorithmic ... subgroups of GLare finitely presented. ... Derek Holt. ... finitely generated soluble group that is not polycyclic, ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Relations in GL(n,C)
    ... Jack Schmidt wrote: ... subgroups of GLare finitely presented. ... This group is isomorphic to the wreath product Z wr Z, ... Derek Holt. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Group of order 1960
    ... >Having trouble with this problem: ... >intersection of two subgroups is a subgroup of both 7-Sylows. ... Derek Holt. ... >Now I'm stuck, because I have many possibilities for n_2. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: ...Cyclic inner automorphism (sub)group
    ... that G is abelian, since G is a union of subgroups, ... implies G=Z, so G is abelian. ... Derek Holt. ...
    (sci.math)

Quantcast