Re: Closing the Intersection
- From: William Elliot <marsh@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Tue, 25 Apr 2006 01:42:06 -0700
From: Jose Capco <cliomseerg@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
William Elliot wrote:
Huh? Some x in cl A/\B with x not in cl A and x not in cl B ?
How is that possible?
x in cl A/\B subset cl A /\ cl B subset cl A, cl B.
Sorry I meant x in cl(A) /\ cl(B) but not in cl(A/\B),
whilst A and B being connected with A/\B nonempty.
So what entirely, is your question?
Frequently I download replies instead of reading online. Thus
in attempts to compensate for your over clipping I'll surmise
you're speculating if A,B are connected, that
cl A/\B = cl A /\ cl B.
Did not my counterexample deter you from that conjecture?
Now a real plane counter example.
Let A be vertical lines with rational x coordinate and B
same with irrational x coordinate. Add x axis to both.
cl A/\B = x axis; cl A /\ cl B = R^2;
----
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: Closing the Intersection
- From: William Elliot
- Re: Closing the Intersection
- References:
- Closing the Intersection
- From: Jose Capco
- Re: Closing the Intersection
- From: William Elliot
- Re: Closing the Intersection
- From: Jose Capco
- Re: Closing the Intersection
- From: William Elliot
- Re: Closing the Intersection
- From: Jose Capco
- Re: Closing the Intersection
- From: William Elliot
- Re: Closing the Intersection
- From: Jose Capco
- Closing the Intersection
- Prev by Date: Re: Algebraic topology question
- Next by Date: Re: Symplectic property
- Previous by thread: Re: Closing the Intersection
- Next by thread: Re: Closing the Intersection
- Index(es):