Min and max are elementary functions?!
- From: David W. Cantrell <DWCantrell@xxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: 04 Jun 2006 12:04:27 GMT
A certain web site lists min and max as being elementary functions.
Before trying to explain to them why their classification of min and max as
elementary was wrong, I decided to ask here:
How would you explain to them what's wrong with that classification?
Of course, I'm assuming that you agree that min and max are not elementary.
But if you think that, somehow, they can legitimately be called elementary,
please tell me why. I expect that the people running the web site will say
that
min(a, b) = 1/2 (a + b - sqrt((a - b)^2))
and
max(a, b) = 1/2 (a + b + sqrt((a - b)^2))
justify classifying min and max as elementary. But of course, for those two
identities to be correct, "sqrt" must be the _principal_ branch. And
there's the rub...
David
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: Min and max are elementary functions?!
- From: The World Wide Wade
- Re: Min and max are elementary functions?!
- From: Dave L. Renfro
- Re: Min and max are elementary functions?!
- From: G. A. Edgar
- Re: Min and max are elementary functions?!
- From: Virgil
- Re: Min and max are elementary functions?!
- From: matt271829-news
- Re: Min and max are elementary functions?!
- From: Dirk Van de moortel
- Re: Min and max are elementary functions?!
- From: N. Silver
- Re: Min and max are elementary functions?!
- Prev by Date: Re: Finding the optimizing distribution
- Next by Date: Poincare Conjecture proof by Xiping Zhu and Huaidong Cao
- Previous by thread: Inverse function questions
- Next by thread: Re: Min and max are elementary functions?!
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|