Galois theory problem: if a^3+a+1=0, does Q(a) contain i=sqrt(-1)?
- From: "Snis Pilbor" <snispilbor@xxxxxxxxx>
- Date: 14 Sep 2006 08:59:21 -0700
Hello, here is yet another qual practice problem I wasn't able to
solve.
"Suppose a is a complex number with a^3+a+1=0. Determine whether or
not sqrt(-1) lies in Q(a)."
Part of the problem is that I'm unable to factor the polynomial, even
over C. I'm sure there is supposed to be a solution which doesn't
involve factoring the polynomial.
The main idea I was trying was to show that [Q(a):Q]=3. If this were
true, sqrt(-1) could not lie in Q(a) because the min polynomial of
sqrt(-1) is degree 2 and 2 does not divide 3. The polynomial has two
real roots and one complex root. If it had one real and two complex,
its Galois group would have S_3, but the converse is false (I think?),
and I don't know how to show that the Galois group is not S_3.
Or heck, maybe the Galois group *is* S_3. I don't know how to tell. I
know that since the polynomial is cubic, there are some fancy tests
using the discriminant to mechanically find the Galois group, but these
are not the kind of things one memorizes by rote, and I doubt they'd
give full credit for such a solution anyway since that material isn't
among the "assumed knowledge" for the qual.
Thanks a ton for any help you can give =)
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: Galois theory problem: if a^3+a+1=0, does Q(a) contain i=sqrt(-1)?
- From: Peter L. Montgomery
- Re: Galois theory problem: if a^3+a+1=0, does Q(a) contain i=sqrt(-1)?
- From: Arturo Magidin
- Re: Galois theory problem: if a^3+a+1=0, does Q(a) contain i=sqrt(-1)?
- From: Achava Nakhash, the Loving Snake
- Re: Galois theory problem: if a^3+a+1=0, does Q(a) contain i=sqrt(-1)?
- Prev by Date: Re: Even armonics
- Next by Date: Re: Misc. questions about "math" in general
- Previous by thread: nur mal so
- Next by thread: Re: Galois theory problem: if a^3+a+1=0, does Q(a) contain i=sqrt(-1)?
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|