Re: JSH: The "Published" paper he dosen't what you to know about.

marcus_b wrote:

<deleted>

One of the simpler cases to which your result should
apply is when f = sqrt(5). In that case, the polynomial
equation above becomes

a^3 + 12 a^2 - 65 = 0.

This is a monic polynomial with integer coefficients.
It is irreducible over the rationals. The roots
are algebraic integers. Dedekind's theorem
and Galois theory both say that none of the roots are
coprime to f^2 = 5 in the ring of algebraic integers.
You however infer that one of the roots IS coprime
to 5. And since you are saying that Galois theory is
wrong, you must be saying that it is wrong in the ring
to which it applies: the ring of algebraic integers.
From which we must conclude: you think one of roots is
coprime to 5 *** in the ring of algebraic integers.***
This is inescapable.


Nope.

Why go in circles? I already note that the result isn't true in the
ring of algebraic integers, so why come back and claim that I'm saying
it's true in the ring of algebraic integers?

It's trivial math too.

You're doing what other posters have tried to do which is claim I'm
saying what I'm not, and denying the reality that I acknowledge that
none of the roots can be coprime to 5 in the ring of algebraic
integers.


James Harris

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: New paper, algebraic integers, Galois Theory
    ... >>You're suggesting that it is possible that one of the roots of the ... existence of common factors requires the context of a ring. ... can find the common factors whose existence you're apparently disputing. ... You have maintained that the ring of algebraic integers is somehow ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: JSH: what is the object ring ??
    ... amaze us with your math definition of an object ring. ... JSH somehow "proves" that 7 has to divide exactly one ... of the roots thereof. ... Factorization theorem to algebraic integers. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: JSH: Psychology of the denial of "core error"
    ... its roots would be in some sort of ... ring be the ring of ... a_1 and a_2 are NOT algebraic integers. ... With errors in mathematics you can get this odd ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: JSH: Inconsistency with algebraic integers
    ... My issue is not with whether or not taking the roots of monic ... polynomials with integer coefficients will give you a ring or not, ... one root has 7 as a factor in the ring of algebraic integers, ... Faux mathematics can be appealing because it allows you to "prove" any ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: JSH: Inconsistency with algebraic integers
    ... My issue is not with whether or not taking the roots of monic ... polynomials with integer coefficients will give you a ring or not, ... one root has 7 as a factor in the ring of algebraic integers, ... Faux mathematics can be appealing because it allows you to "prove" any ...
    (sci.math)