Re: JSH: Stop being dense



willo_thewisp@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
Tim Peters wrote:


As best I can make out, the only specific result
of Dedekind's you ever objected to here was this one (which he did indeed
prove using the theory of ideals):

Given algebraic integers a and b, and given that a and b are
coprime in the algebraic integers, there exist algebraic integers
a' and b' such that

a*a' + b*b' = 1

Is that the result you challenge? If so, why do you challenge it? Or if
not, what /are/ you talking about?



This hardly deserves to be called a "result"; it's an immediate
consequence
of the definition. The only thing you need to use ideal theory for is
to
define "coprime" in the first place.


Not quite. An important consequence of Dedekind's work on
ideals here was that, in the ring of algebraic integers, any two
numbers have a greatest common divisor - that is, if a and b are
algebraic integers, there exist other algebraic integers r, s, and
t such that

a = r*t and

b = s*t

and if u is another algebraic integer which divides both a and b,
then u divides t. If a and b are coprime, then you can take t to
be 1.

Marcus.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: JSH: The "Published" paper he dosent what you to know about.
    ... I'm not sure what he wants from his "object ring", ... so the other factors needed to be coprime to f --- in the ring ... happen in the ring of algebraic integers. ... Dedekind's work and the theory of ideals. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: JSH: Understanding the rebuttal
    ... the ring of algebraic integers. ... necessity then that solution will ... group via multiplication of ideals, ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: JSH: Understanding the rebuttal
    ... the ring of algebraic integers. ... For instance, if g is a multiple of 5, then one can solve ... group via multiplication of ideals, ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: JSH: Stop being dense
    ... |every proper ideal in the algebraic integers is contained ... The case of the axiom of choice that a proof ... any prime ideals that divide both elements, ... aside, this differs from just defining it to mean = ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: JSH: The "Published" paper he dosent what you to know about.
    ... mean when they say two elements of a ring are coprime, ... except) when the ring is Z. ... concludes two algebraic integers are coprime, when if you look at his ... although he has shown no contradiction of the theory of ideals ...
    (sci.math)