Re: Continuous maps and extending into closure



In article <1162400198.682463.258770@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
Jason Pawloski <jpawloski@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
If f:X->X is a continuous function on some metric space, and for some
subset of X denoted K, f(K) is a subset of K, how do I show that f(K~)
is a subset of K~ where K~ is the closure of K.

If you don't mind, I'll use cl(K) instead of K~. It's just so I won't
make a mistake...

Proving f(cl(K)) is contained in cl(K) is equivalent to proving that
X\cl(K) is contained in X\f(cl(K)). So let x be in the complement of
K~; we want to show that x is in the complement of f(cl(K)).

If x is not in f(X), then we are done. So assume that there exists y
such that f(y) = x.

Since cl(K) is closed, X\cl(K) is closed. So there exists e>0 such
that B(x,e), the open ball with center in x and radius e, is contained
in X\cl(K).

Since f is continuous, and f(y)=x, there exists a d>0 such that
f(B(y,d)) is contained in B(x,e). In particular, f(B(y,d))/\cl(K) is
empty. Since f(K) is contained in K, that means that B(y,d)/\K is
empty (if z were in B(y,d)/\K, then f(z) would be both in B(x,e) and
in f(K), which is contained in K, which is contained in cl(K)).

Therefore, there is a neighborhood of y which is disjoint from K, so y
is not in cl(K). Therefore, f(y) is not in f(cl(K)). But since f(y)=x,
that means that x is not in f(cl(K)), which is what we wanted to
prove.


--
======================================================================
"It's not denial. I'm just very selective about
what I accept as reality."
--- Calvin ("Calvin and Hobbes" by Bill Watterson)
======================================================================

Arturo Magidin
magidin-at-member-ams-org

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Peanos Axioms are Inconsistent
    ... The predicate for cell z being blank at step x: ... Your statement that the set of blank positions being empty is equivalent ... This negative is equivalent to saying that there exists no largest ... is by proving the set of blank positions is empty. ...
    (comp.theory)
  • Re: Peanos Axioms are Inconsistent
    ... set of blank positions is empty. ... ambiguity is ruinous in mathematics. ... is by proving the set of blank positions is empty. ... member of X is it? ...
    (comp.theory)
  • Re: Complement in Relational Lattice
    ... the complement of an empty relation is not unique. ... So for a given header, the complement is unique if the value ... What you have found is a homomorphism of RL into a boolean algebra ...
    (comp.databases.theory)
  • Re: "separate entity" and individuation in mathematics
    ... > Jim Spriggs wrote: ... > by describing it as the complement of the closure of the complement ... > both of these extensions rewrite to two of the above, ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: "separate entity" and individuation in mathematics
    ... > Jim Spriggs wrote: ... > by describing it as the complement of the closure of the complement ... > both of these extensions rewrite to two of the above, ...
    (sci.logic)