Re: Cantor Confusion

In article <1167759460.349040.128220@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
mueckenh@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:

Franziska Neugebauer schrieb:

Where is a contradiction?

Read the quote below. Your answers to my questions 2 and 3 constitute a
contradiction. Please correct me if I'm wrong: #

You are wrong.

That is not a correction, burt an unproven claim.

Your answer to my question 2 states

x is identical to y
<-> there is no difference between x and y (P)

Correct. x is an idea. It is identical to the entity which you call an
irrational number, i.e., an idea y.

Your answer to question 3 states

x is different from y (due to some reason)
<-> there is a difference between x and y (Q)

You simply fail to distinguish sharply enough between y and y'.
x is different from y', i.e., from what you think an irrational number
is., i.e., from an idea which can be approximated to any given
precision by rational numbers.

That is by your definition, not anyone else's, so is only valid in your
non-system, not anyone else's.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Help with Conditional Code
    ... If you fail to quote, I will fail to respond further] ... the option to select another language. ... Your unwillingness to quote has dropped the implementation ... Books today and could not find one book on Jscript. ...
    (microsoft.public.scripting.jscript)
  • Re: Opinions on the Law Of Demeter
    ... the relevant quote that you miss is: ... "In addition we *believe* that programs which obey the law are more ... contradiction to the Law of Demeter." ... Now, contrary to your handwaving claims, the author themselves do not ...
    (comp.object)
  • Re: Announcing A New Unifying Principle of the Evolutionary
    ... >> Once again you fail to provide any evidence - it is hard to take your ... > essentially declaring that it is consistent with *all* of the evidence. ... It cannot be consistent with its contradiction, ... Independent Researcher ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: "Relativity and Reasonableness Tests"
    ... Would you PLEASE learn to cite the source being quoted so that readers can ... You quote people but fail to show whom is being quoted. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Mathematicians are in deep shit for 2 reasons
    ... [begin elsimelsi quote] ... LST proves that systems with uncountable models ... Suber did NOT say "NOTE A CONTRADICTION". ... isomorphism. ...
    (sci.logic)