Re: Cantor For Dummies ...

I never said that the list being fed in was
the output list. Never once did I say that
an output list was being used as input. I'd
be interested to see where you claim I said
that an output list was being used as input.

You said that your algorithm can use ANY input.

Yes. I said that if you provide a list of
committees, then my algorithm can and will
produce a committee that's not on your list.

No it can't. It can't use a list that
contains your algorithm's output.

Why not?

If you start with a list L1 of committees and
then apply my algorithm to that, we get a new
committee C1 that wasn't on the original list.

Now create a list L2 which is C1 prepended to L1.

Tell me why we can't now apply my algorithm
to L2.
.

Quantcast