Re: Thinking about metric spaces

On Jun 27, 5:57 pm, quasi <q...@xxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Wed, 27 Jun 2007 19:29:16 -0500, quasi <q...@xxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Wed, 27 Jun 2007 11:25:02 -0700, bit188 <mari...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote:

Thanks everyone.

Tommy1729: as regarding my "intentions" with this space, I was going
to... eh, *try* and define angles and trigonometry, but apparantly
that's not a good idea.

Well, it's an interesting idea.

For example, the law of cosines is one possible way.

I think you'd do better _not_ buying the taxicab book.

Play with the ideas yourself at an elementary level. So what if you
end up reinventing the wheel? At the early levels, almost anything you
try has been tried before and analyzed more completely than you
probably would do. Knowing that takes a lot of the joy out of
exploration. Of course, you should read the real theories, but on the
more experimental stuff, I say just try it. Don't even ask if it was
done before (since the answer will almost always be yes).

It's just not as much fun to read what someone else did.

Trying it yourself gives you the sense (even if illusory) of math
research -- it's exciting and builds self-confidence. Even the failed
attempts help develop critical intuition.

As an example of what I'm talking about, here's a simple question.

In a metric space X, to say 3 points a,b,c are collinear means what?

There are various possible answers, some more natural than others, but
if you haven't yet thought about or seen a discussion of this
question, it has value as a thought experiment. Will any answer you
propose be sound? Maybe, maybe not, but either way, that's the
experience you want. If the idea is sound, will it be new? Probably
not, but who cares?

quasi

I suppose you're right.

It really bums me out, though, that I don't have the ability to be
original in my work yet. I know so little about math as it is now.

It makes me want to work as hard as I can to learn math faster. So I
guess it's good for motivation. :D

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: 1985 Toyota Tercel wagon with loud bumping sound
    ... It got louder, so I thought it was because we didn't turn the rotors. ... the wheel is straight ahead again. ... Does the sound stay the same regardless of vehicle speed and engine RPM ... The sound increases with the speed of the car, ...
    (alt.autos.toyota)
  • Wheel Bearings or Warped Rotor Chevy Caprice
    ... At 40 mph with light braking I get a sharp wobble in the steering ... I also get the cyclic pulsing. ... Starting about 4,000 miles ago I began to hear a droning sound from the ... when moving the wheel back and forth. ...
    (rec.autos.tech)
  • Re: 94 Olds Cutlass Ciera wheel bearing going bad?
    ... automatic transmission because when I put it in neutral while driving ... down the road and let the engine idle - the sound is the same. ... guessing that it is a wheel bearing just starting to go bad. ...
    (rec.autos.tech)
  • Re: 1985 Toyota Tercel wagon with loud bumping sound
    ... The sound was almost gone, then returned with a vengeance in one day. ... wheel is straight ahead again. ... Since it stops when I turn to the right, I figure it couldn't possibly be ... It needs to be fixed right away, since my girlfriend needs it to travel to ...
    (alt.autos.toyota)
  • Re: Almost-random noise
    ... greased the spoke crossings of the "bad" wheel to no effect. ... J. Brandt notes that I must have missed a recent topic. ... but I wasn't sure that the "cracking" sound ... (To those concerned with possible creeping handlebar/seatpost/frame ...
    (rec.bicycles.tech)