Re: polygons circumscribing a circle



In article <1184610934.877197.106720@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
Musing <generalizing@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

How does one show that the perimeter of a regular polygon
circumscribing a circle is greater than the circumference (of the
circle)? Thanks.

Here's a calculus proof, working on the unit circle. Suppose 0 < b <
1. The line from (0,0) to (1,b) intersects the circle at a point
(sqrt(1-a^2), a). We want to show the arc-length from (1,0) to
(sqrt(1-a^2), a) along the circle is < b.

Similar triangles show b/1 = a/sqrt(1-a^2). The arc in question is
parameterized by (f(y),y), 0 <= y <= a, where f(y) = sqrt(1-y^2). The
calculus definition of the arc-length is int_[0,a] sqrt(1 + f'(y)^2)
dy. A simple computation shows sqrt(1 + f'(y)^2) = 1/sqrt(1-y^2). So
we are trying to show

a/sqrt(1-a^2) > int_[0,a] 1/sqrt(1-y^2) dy.

But the integrand is a strictly increasing positive function of y, so
its integral is less than the length of the interval times its value
at the right-hand end point, namely, a*1/sqrt(1-a^2).
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: "pi"
    ... and diameter of a circle. ... So instead you measure the perimeter of an ... inscribed polygon, which takes short-cuts compared to the circle, ... that the length of a circumscribing ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: polygons circumscribing a circle
    ... circumscribing a circle is greater than the circumference (of the ... in the interior of another convex polygon, ... than the perimeter of the second polygon. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Hexagon cutting tablesaw jig
    ... Isosceles triangles, each with an included angle of 60 degrees. ... circle concentric with the hexagon and passing through the vertices. ... radius of the hexagon's circumscribing circle. ...
    (rec.woodworking)
  • Re: polygons circumscribing a circle
    ... circumscribing a circle is greater than the circumference (of the ... The area of the triangle ABD is 1/2 the length of tangent BD times ... Piece together the sides of the circumscribing polygon using this ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: polygons circumscribing a circle
    ... circumscribing a circle is greater than the circumference (of the ... Any answer to how one compares the perimeter ... limit of all perimeters of circumscribing polygons. ...
    (sci.math)

Quantcast