Re: JSH: Problem space, counting down on DMESE



On Sat, 27 Oct 2007 17:39:13 -0700, gjedwards@xxxxxxxxx wrote:

As you are forever reminded, you won't ever produce anything
interesting unless you are prepared to actually learn about a subject,
be that math, encryption, or anything else.

That's especially true for the major problems in a subject - you can
be sure that they have been studied incredibly hard. There are
occasional recreational problems (like Galvin's paper folding) that
an amateur may pick up from time to time, but you can be sure that
there's nothing truly revolutionary in their solution.

An amateur is exceedingly unlikely to find a short proof of FLT, or to
resolve the RH.

Only an idiot would waste time looking at these problems without
reading about what others had done.
Newton quoted "standing on the shoulders of giants". JSH seems to
think that he is a giant and so does not need to stand on anyone's
shoulders.

He is mistaken.

rossum

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Long threads, tactics
    ... > its way around the world, as I move Google search results. ... > of an electronic math journal. ... If you disagree, please say why. ... whereas you are an Amateur. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Sociological/Psychological Phenomenon
    ... > that they have no competence. ... > What is it about math in particular, ... Mathematics is a purely abstract endeavor that can be done ... are _you_ competent enough to tell the bumbling amateur from the ...
    (sci.crypt)
  • Re: Encryption newbie - Same length encrypted result
    ... > I'm a software guy with an amateur interest in encryption. ... Your encrypted database, should not be the same as you unencrypted database, ... Any virus smart enough to penetrate ...
    (sci.crypt)
  • Re: Sociological/Psychological Phenomenon
    ... >What is it about math and crypto that makes an amateur ... >What is it about math in particular, ... But they do not seem to look for fame by semi-serious ... They know they lack skills for the latter. ...
    (sci.crypt)
  • Object-oriented solution to Tower of Hanoi
    ... pretty amateur, but I've been a programmer for about 6 years and up ... until now have gotten away with knowing little about math (real math -- ... They're longer than an equivalent solution in math would be, ...
    (comp.lang.ruby)