Re: Confirmation of Shannon's Mistake about Perfect Secrecy of One-time-pad

On 11 7 , 8 20 , William Hughes <wpihug...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Nov 7, 4:24 am, wangyong <hell...@xxxxxxx> wrote:

On 11 7 , 4 51 , William Hughes <wpihug...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

... as we know that M is not uniform we conclude that
the assumption that K is uniform when C is fixed
is incorrect.

====yes,

Good, you understand. Now stop claiming that K
must be uniform when C is fixed. It might be, but
it might not be.

but what can you conclude.

That if we do not know whether or not M is uniform,
we do not know if whether or not K is uniform when
C is fixed.

Thus

If we consider only the OTP without considering the
prior probability on M, we do not know whether
of not M is uniform. So if we consider only the OTP
and a fixed C we do not know whether or not
K is uniform.

- William Hughes

Good, you understand. Now stop claiming that K
must be uniform when C is fixed. It might be, but
it might not be.
=========you should know what is precondition, in that case i
regardless of M prior

note I say:"
I just regardless one of the conditions such as M prior and K
uniform
to make show there need a compromise . "






but what can you conclude.


That if we do not know whether or not M is uniform,
we do not know if whether or not K is uniform when
C is fixed.

Thus


If we consider only the OTP without considering the
prior probability on M, we do not know whether
of not M is uniform. So if we consider only the OTP
and a fixed C we do not know whether or not
K is uniform.
====== my precondition is not the same as you,do not falsify my
statement
i consider C fixed, k uniform, regardless P prior
i consider C fixed, P Prior , regardless k uniform
under the two Probability are conflicting.



.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: different priors (flat, uniform, etc)
    ... It CHANGES the likelihood function to form the posterior distr. ... because they is the KEY to any PROPER prior ... the uniform distribution is hardly diffuse. ...
    (sci.stat.math)
  • Re: Help needed with expletives
    ... RL> It is, in fact, precisely what was being worked toward prior ... RL> to the blowup. ... The uniform, concerted, and poisonously ... RL> vociferous response of The "Gay Community" has been and ...
    (rec.arts.sf.composition)
  • Re: he might used deep, unless Margaret depicts lectures with Ramsis winner
    ... They are starting as roman, despite doubtful, prior to bitter editions. ... If you will check Chris's psychologist over examples, it will under foster the uniform. ...
    (sci.crypt)
  • Re: Help needed with expletives
    ... Charlton Wilbur wrote: ... RL> It is, in fact, precisely what was being worked toward prior ... RL> to the blowup. ... The uniform, concerted, and poisonously ...
    (rec.arts.sf.composition)
  • Re: Isnt the Frequentist a subset or special case of Bayesianist?
    ... >>My shallow understanding of the Frequentist is that he puts a uniform ... If so, isn't this just a special case of the Bayesian approach, ... >>where the prior can be anything, ... Such a Bayesian if NOT using any MLE as a non-Bayesian does. ...
    (sci.stat.math)