Re: Venkat!

On Dec 17, 11:05 pm, Virgil <Vir...@xxxxxxx> wrote:
In article
<5668d50c-d847-4002-b613-ac3f06f03...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
Venkat Reddy <vred...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

May be you are taking all my posts to be some sort of proofs after
thorough research and intended to change whatever is in text books.
No, you are mistaken. It is a discussion. Do you know what is a
discussion?

When you keep saying "This is the way things are!" instead saying "Is
this the way things are?" it doesn't look much like you are "discussing".


No, it's not. He keeps coming up with new axioms and not even
proposing them as such, taking them as though they were the
already known axioms...



What's the purpose of a discussion group if you can't tolerate a
thought process that attempts to explore a bit around the established
concepts, though by faltering steps and seeks guidance? Remember, only
new perspectives, though flamed to be wrong, can get some progress.

When one is asking for guidance, as you claim to be doing, one must be
prepared to have one's errors pointed out.


Yes, exactly.



Otherwise, stick to your books, and don't come back until you can
participate in discussions with tolerance. And stop correcting others
if you can't do that without showing your bad temper. Learn to
discuss.

We will be quite happy without you, but as we were here first, perhaps
you should not dictate to us.


If he had something *truly* logical, then it does not matter
who was here "first", and he could dictate it. But it's not
logical.



And this applies to everyone, who find it easy to spew their bad slang
here, and feel that they are providing entertainment to others.

You claim to want to learn, but then you try and dictate how things have
to be.

We find that insulting and bad tempered.


I don't. I just think he doesn't want to learn anything, and
that's his choice and his problem.

So if anyone should quit, it should be you.


But does that make it right to attack him even more --
more evil does not make good appear.

That or learn to mind your manners when asking for instruction.


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Venkat!
    ... thorough research and intended to change whatever is in text books. ... What's the purpose of a discussion group if you can't tolerate a ... When one is asking for guidance, as you claim to be doing, one must be ... if you can't do that without showing your bad temper. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: The Muslims are coming! The Muslims are coming!
    ... Instead of arguing personalities, philosophy, pseudo-history, etc., why not read the original article and dig into Sperry's claimed "facts"? ... For guidance, find out what people are saying after Sperry's material stimulated them. ...
    (misc.news.internet.discuss)
  • Re: Eric Gisse doesnt know the basics of Relativity
    ... doesn't understand now as evidenced by his latest little temper ... Every so often he has to spam this newsgroup with about 20 ... posts saying how stupid I am and whatever. ... Actually Paul Anderson gave a web link to the answer above (T' = gamma ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: GURPS Powers - no frikkin examples!
    ... > Yes, it does look very crunchy, I am only saying I would have appreciated ... > a bit of guidance in how to use the rules to produce something like those ... how to make powers using Characters. ...
    (rec.games.frp.gurps)
  • Re: Just shoot me!
    ... > A buddy of mine who I've been trying to get to control his temper after a bad ... > beat was saying something similar about his cards never hitting, ...
    (rec.gambling.poker)
Quantcast