Re: Length and area..



On Sun, 06 Apr 2008 09:19:22 EDT, "G.E. Ivey"
<george.ivey@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

On Apr 5, 2:43 pm, "[Mr.] Lynn Kurtz"
<ku...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
2, 0. Your second figure doesn't enclose any area
unless I
misinterpret the meaning of the dotted lines.

I'm pretty sure that what the OP intended was to find
the area of a
rectangle in which the segment on the right side of
the rectangle is
not included in the area. I.e., if you put the origin
of a Cartesian
coordinate system at the lower left corner of the
rectangle with the
+x axis directed along the base of the rectangle,
then the region in
question satisfies 0 <= x < 2 and 0 <= y <= 1.

Dave
If so that would be a very silly question. Any student advanced enough to know the distinction between "dotted" and "solid" lines could trivially do the area. And if they didn't know that, and just calculated the area of the rectangle anyway, they would get the correct answer anyway. What would such a question be testing?

Whether the area of a closed rectangular region is affected by the
removal of part of the boundary.

The exercise (clearly very elementary) is presumably intended to show
by example that the concept of "positive measure" depends on the
dimension of the containing space, and hence positive length doesn't
imply positive area.

quasi
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: e^z = z
    ... Timothy Murphy writes: ... But I am looking for a solution at a lower level. ... Consider the image under f of the rectangle with corners 0, N, ... The image of the segment 0 to N goes along the positive real ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: e^z = z
    ... On Apr 2, 12:08 pm, Robert Israel ... Consider the image under f of the rectangle with corners 0, N, ... The image of the segment 0 to N goes along the positive real ... is within distance N+2 pi of a counterclockwise circular arc, ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: School Geometry Question
    ... square ABCD is a rectangle and angle FOA is 90 degree. ... Right triangles ABC and AOF are similar by aa. ... This is clearly an exercise on similar triangles ... is a bottomless pit full of trolls (infinite trolls, ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: equidistant sets
    ... >>construction, but I'll still need some time to review the construction ... >mean they are opposite sides of a rectangle. ... >My concave polygon construction is based on adjusting the lengths of the ... (Just follow your tactic of placing a line segment with the proper ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: line segment
    ... Prove that a line segment has content zero. ... But "rectangle" here probably means "rectangle with sides parallel to ... Hence the graph of f has content 0.) ...
    (sci.math)