Re: opponents of taylor and l'hospital ?



amy666 <tommy1729@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

some while ago when talking about limits , i used l'hospitals rule
or taylor series. i was then told by certain people that they dont
like l'hospitals rule nor taylor series. they said l'hospitals rule
was overrated ! can those people plz explain what is it that makes
them opponents of l'hospital rule and taylor series ??
i dont see a downside of l'hospitals rule ? and i was quite amazed
to read that on a mathforum from even relative regular posters.

There is in fact an _algorithm_ for evaluating limits of a wide class
of elementary functions that I discovered around 1980. In a rough
sense the algorithm works by computing certain generalized power
series expansions (or initial terms thereof), so it may be viewed
as an amalgam of applying taylor series and L'Hospital's rule. More
precisely it works by computing higher-rank valuations in certain
(Hardy-Rosenlicht) differential fields. There are probably only
a handful of mathematicians familiar with such techniques, so one
can safely say that almost all responses you receive here will
not be well-informed. See my prior post [1] and its links for
some nontrivial examples and further remarks.

--Bill Dubuque

[1] http://google.com/groups?selm=y8zk7js12ba.fsf%40nestle.ai.mit.edu
.



Relevant Pages

  • opponents of taylor and lhospital ?
    ... some while ago when talking about limits, i used l'hospitals rule or taylor series. ... i was then told by certain people that they dont like l'hospitals rule nor taylor series. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: reply to "Re:...conventions...,0^0=?"
    ... Only when taking limits. ... the formula for the Taylor series of a function: ... so 0^0 is defined as 1 with dealing with polynomials ... --- Christopher Heckman ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: erf function in C
    ... > And what about the inverse cumulative normal distribution? ... > I used to implement an algorithm you published, ... should serve very well for solving the equation ... values Aand Bto initalize the Taylor series ...
    (comp.lang.c)
  • Re: erf function in C
    ... Would you still recommend this? ... Is there another fast but portable algorithm with sufficient ... > should serve very well for solving the equation ... the Taylor series was easy and fast only for the first few ...
    (comp.lang.c)
  • Re: Algorithm for calculating matrix exponential
    ... I am a programmer and I will like most of all to see an algorithm, ... Taylor series approach is probably a good one. ... diagonalizing the matrix should be considered. ...
    (sci.math)

Loading