Re: Open sets and proper mapping



On 27-01-2009 15:17, jane wrote:

I have the following question:

Let f be a holomorphic map on C and U,V are open subsets of C such that closure(U) in V.
Is it true that then closure(f(U)) in f(V).

Here is my argument: since f is holomorphic it is proper and therefore is closed, i.e. maps closed sets to closed sets.

Who told you that holomorphic maps are proper? The exponential is a non-proper entire function (and in fact it gives a counterexample to
your original question if you choose the right U and V. Hint:
0 is not in exp(V).

Ok. Thanks, i see your point. Well, actually i need this fact nor for general holomorphic functions, but for rational functions. If i am not mistaken a rational function has a finite degree and it is a finite degree branched covering, therefore it must be proper and the argument should work in this case.

Am i right now in the case f is a rational function? (Or even finite-degree branched covering).

No. Take f(z) = 1/z and take D = { z in C | |z| >= 1 }. Then D is
closed, but f(D) is not.

Best regards,

Jose Carlos Santos
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Open sets and proper mapping
    ... Let f be a holomorphic map on C and U,V are open ... Who told you that holomorphic maps are proper? ... Am i right now in the case f is a rational function? ... That would make a mockery of everything Godel was ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Open sets and proper mapping
    ... Let f be a holomorphic map on C and U,V are open ... i.e. maps closed sets ... The first counterexample I thought of was 1/z, ... "Understanding Godel isn't about following his formal ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Open sets and proper mapping
    ... Let f be a holomorphic map on C and U,V are open subsets of C such that closurein V. ... since f is holomorphic it is proper and therefore is closed, i.e. maps closed sets to closed sets. ... "Understanding Godel isn't about following his formal proof. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Open sets and proper mapping
    ... Let f be a holomorphic map on C and U,V are open ... i.e. maps closed sets ... Am i right now in the case f is a rational function? ... "Understanding Godel isn't about following his formal ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Open sets and proper mapping
    ... Let f be a holomorphic map on C and U,V are open subsets ... i.e. maps closed sets to closed sets. ... Jose Carlos Santos ...
    (sci.math)