Re: Is this proof of infinitely many primes flawed?

On Fri, 30 Jan 2009 05:09:39 -0600, David C. Ullrich
<dullrich@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

I didn't make any claims about what it was or was
not "likely" that the OP was asking, just about what
he did in fact ask:

"how can we say p_k  divides evenly (p_1,p_2,...,p_n)?"

There is after all a context.

Yes. The context _seems_ to be that he was confused,
thinking that the answer to his (trivial) question had
something to do with that other assumption, which
it doesn't.

Actually, I think the confusion might in fact stem from the use of
commas instead of a standard product symbol.

Of course, it makes no sense at all to think that p_k would divide
evenly into a _list_ of distinct primes, so _we_ (on sci,math) just
assumed (knowing how the correct proof goes) that the comma was
intended as a product symbol. But the OP (who may simply have copied
it incorrectly off the board in class), may have interpreted the
expression (p_1,p_2,...,p_n) as a list, hence the puzzlement.

quasi
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Is this proof of infinitely many primes flawed?
    ... The context _seems_ to be that he was confused, ... I think the confusion might in fact stem from the use of ... commas instead of a standard product symbol. ...
    (sci.math)
  • =?UTF-8?Q?Re=3A_Bamboo_=E7=AD=92_is_called_copper_coin=2E_Why=3F?=
    ... history, people have confused homophones - sometimes it's called ... interchangeably when the meaning in context altered unintentionally. ... It's even foolishness, causing confusion and ... square holes, it certainly suggests it. ...
    (rec.games.mahjong)
  • Re: Tax Class
    ... I am so fricking dumb. ... And if they want to go head to head with me on the current state of ... I made very clear the context of what was a completely hypothetical ... they never seem to be in the befuddled mass of confusion the others ...
    (alt.smokers.cigars)
  • Re: Is this proof of infinitely many primes flawed?
    ... I think the confusion might in fact stem from the use of ... commas instead of a standard product symbol. ... but used a "middle dot" for multiplication, ... Unfortunately, the student, not ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Need help with translation
    ... >>Doug Wickstrom wrote: ... >>> confusion. ... >>I assume from the context that both sons are ... >>grammar, and there may be differences between ...
    (soc.genealogy.nordic)